Lessons from Communism
Ilya Shambat <[email protected]> Sat, 7 Oct 2023 21:39:41 -0700 (PDT)
| Newsgroups | alt.angst |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
There are lessons that stand to be learned from just about everything. I am= now focusing on lessons that should come from the world=E2=80=99s experien= ce of Communism. The main lesson from Communism is that you don=E2=80=99t get to keep people= =E2=80=99s loyalty for long if you insist on treating your workers like dir= t. When a section of a population is being mistreated, it is only a matter = of time before someone comes along and caters to that. With Communism, the = hardest lessons were learned by places like Russia and China, where abuses = were the worst, and the least hard lessons were learned by places like Amer= ica, where the abuses were the least. We have some in conservatism claiming that anyone who=E2=80=99s had anythin= g to do with Communism is evil. In fact most people who supported Communism= came from the right place. They didn=E2=80=99t like seeing workers being m= istreated. They didn=E2=80=99t like seeing women being mistreated. They did= n=E2=80=99t like seeing people of other races being mistreated. Many of the= se people were ethical and compassionate. Much more so than people who want= them lynched. While Marxism itself is wrong =E2=80=93 and I have written about all the wa= ys in which Marxism is wrong =E2=80=93 it doesn=E2=80=99t take an evil pers= on to want to improve the conditions for workers, women and other races. Al= l this does not require a revolution and can be done within the framework o= f capitalism and democracy. When I worked in the computer industry I did no= t feel exploited. I was being paid right and I was being treated right. The= se people in business have learned their lesson from Communism, and they ma= de correct changes in their practices. It is in no way valid to advocate for slaughter of propertied class. It is = however valid to work to improve conditions for workers, women and other ra= ces. Once again, this does not require a revolution; it can be done within = the framework of the system that we have now. There are many valid arguments in favor of business being good to the worke= rs. There is an argument toward compassion =E2=80=93 that the worker has a = family to support. There is an argument toward reason =E2=80=93 that the wo= rker is working hard and should be correctly compensated. There is an argum= ent toward the Golden Rule. One does not have to be a Commie to care about = such things. Both rationality and Christianity favor this approach. And a p= erson claiming to practice either has it demanded of himself that he treat = people in general =E2=80=93 and his workers in particular - well. There are also many valid arguments in favor of better treatment of the env= ironment. What we have here is timeless treasures that man has not created = and cannot recreate. These should be protected, even as the world goes on w= ith scientific and technological progress. This being done, the more idealistically minded people will work within the= system instead of advocating for a revolution. They will find home in the = capitalist system in fields that they can believe in. And the same people w= ho are now troublemakers will becomes significant contributors, applying wh= at is in many cases extraordinary creative intelligence to come up with and= implement real solutions to the problems of the world.