Toilets and changing rooms must be used on basis of biological sex, guidance confirms

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c0e2rj3zj02o

Single-sex spaces - such as changing rooms and toilets - must be used on
the basis of biological sex, new guidance from the equalities watchdog
has confirmed. 

This means, for instance, that a trans woman - a biological male who
identifies as a woman - should not use female toilets or changing rooms,
according to the code of practice. 

The guidance, produced by the Equalities and Human Rights Commission
(EHRC) and now approved by ministers, makes it clear that transgender
people should instead be offered a third or a gender-neutral space. 

The code states that leaving a trans person without access to any
services or facilities would be unlikely to be proportionate and could
be discriminatory. 

The guidance was published on Thursday following the landmark Supreme
Court ruling last year that the definition of a woman under the Equality
Act should be based on biological sex. 

The code of practice sets out how associations, businesses and services
open to the public should organise their facilities. It covers a wide
range of settings from shopping centres and gyms to hospitals and
restaurants. 

With the guidance now before Parliament, MPs and peers have 40 days to
raise any concerns. If there are no objections, the guidance becomes
statutory. 

Women and equalities minister Bridget Phillipson said the aim of the
guidance was to allow people to live free from discrimination and
harassment. 

"Our focus has always been making sure organisations have clear,
accessible guidance on how to implement the law," she said. 

Within the guidance, it was recommended that gender neutral toilets or
changing rooms should have self-contained lockable areas with
floor-to-ceiling walls and wash basins. 

The watchdog said it did not think the requirements would be too onerous
as services could decide to let trans people use toilets for disabled
people, for example. 

The EHRC also said if a service just had two toilets - one for men and
one for women - they could be changed into unisex facilities. 

The guidance, which is more than 300 pages long, was first sent to the
government in September 2025. 

The EHRC said it expected ministers to spend six weeks examining it
before either asking for revisions or placing it before Parliament. 

Instead, the government said it would deal with the issue "thoroughly
and carefully", and took eight months to release the guidance. 

EHRC chair Dr Mary-Ann Stephenson said she hoped people would read the
code with an "open mind". 

"I think we do need to broaden out the debates, and we need to start
from a point of saying, how do we make sure that everyone has access to
the services they need, and that will be different things for different
people," she said. 

At the Watershed arts cinema in Bristol, chief executive Clare
Reddington said they pride themselves on being inclusive. 

She said it had taken too long for the guidance to be published which
has led to confusion and misinformation. 

Reddington described the impact on trans people as "toxic", and said
they had been waiting to hear what the guidance meant "for their ability
to live a full public life". 

The Watershed has gender neutral toilets, which won a Loo of the Year
award in 2024. 

The brightly coloured cubicles have floor-to-ceiling doors, and some
have sinks inside. They also have separate male and female toilets. 

"I would say that designing toilets for everyone is great for business,"
Reddington said. 

'Fewer rights'
Maya Forstater, of Sex Matters, a gender-critical women's rights group,
said: "Finally, there are no more excuses for the many public and
private sector organisations that said they were 'waiting for guidance'
before fixing their unlawful policies. 

"The government's long delay in placing the updated code of practice
before Parliament was seized on as cover by organisations that preferred
to break the law than enrage trans lobby groups. 

"The new guidance is long and detailed, but at its heart is a simple
principle: 'sex' means what it says – male and female. What people call
themselves and how they dress doesn't change their sex. 

"Any business, charity or public service provider that took a wrong turn
and started letting men who identify as women use women's spaces or vice
versa must now urgently fix its policies." 

But a spokesperson for TransActual, a trans rights campaign group, said
the guidance left trans people with fewer rights. 

"Not only does this new guidance fail to protect the rights and dignity
of transgender people, but appears to have weakened protections for the
LGBT community as a whole," they said. 

"TransActual will continue to fight for equal access to public life for
all trans people, and will publish our full thoughts on the new code
once we have had the time to properly scrutinise it." 

Joanne Moseley, of Irwin Mitchell Solicitors, said she is being
regularly asked to provide advice to business and services on what they
need to do. 

She believes that good signage and, where appropriate, ensuring that a
gender-neutral space is available are important. 

She said some businesses and employers made changes to their facilities
immediately after the Supreme Court judgement, but others are putting
off doing anything until the EHRC guidance comes into force. 

However, she warned the guidance was not "a silver bullet" and that if
someone made a claim of discrimination against an organisation it was
not a defence to say "we're waiting for the guidance". 


-- 
November 5, 2024 - Congratulations President Donald Trump.  We look
forward to America being great again. 

We live in a time where intelligent people are being silenced so that
stupid people won't be offended. 

Every day is an IQ test. Some pass, some, not so much.

Thank you for cleaning up the disasters of the 2008-2017, 2020-2024
Obama / Biden / Harris fiascos, President Trump. 

Under Barack Obama's leadership, the United States of America became the
The World According To Garp.  Obama sold out heterosexuals for Hollywood
queer liberal democrat donors.