Observations with cdrecord-2.01.01a64 -minfo
"Thomas Schmitt" <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.comp.audio.cd-record |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <[email protected]> |
Hi Joerg,
while exploring the behavior of cdrecord -minfo
i noticed some problems and some output which i
deem not totally consistent with the user's
perception of media type and state.
Potential bugs:
- Option -eject prevents -minfo output.
- "Phys disk size" gets computed from BD Disc
Type Identifier strings "BDR", "BDW".
Unexpected drive behavior:
- (Pseudo-) BD-ROM track size larger than read
capacity.
Odd statements forwarded from MMC conformant drive
replies:
- Is "incomplete/appendable BD-ROM" intentional ?
- Shall one really declare overwriteable media
"erasable" and "complete" ?
In detail:
------------------------------------------------
This run with -minfo -eject ends quite early:
# cdrecord-2.01.01a64 dev=5,0,0 -minfo -eject
Cdrecord-ProDVD-ProBD-Clone 2.01.01a64 (x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu) Copyright (C) 1995-2009 Jörg Schilling
scsidev: '5,0,0'
scsibus: 5 target: 0 lun: 0
Linux sg driver version: 3.5.27
Using libscg version 'schily-0.9'.
Device type : Removable CD-ROM
Version : 0
Response Format: 2
Capabilities :
Vendor_info : 'HL-DT-ST'
Identifikation : 'BDDVDRW GGC-H20L'
Revision : '1.03'
Device seems to be: Generic mmc2 DVD-R/DVD-RW/DVD-RAM.
Using generic SCSI-3/mmc-3 DVD+R driver (mmc_dvdplusr).
Driver flags : NO-CD DVD MMC-3 SWABAUDIO BURNFREE
Supported modes: PACKET SAO LAYER_JUMP
#
It seems to happen with any type of media.
The same run without -eject tells -minfo lines:
# cdrecord-2.01.01a64 dev=5,0,0 -minfo
Cdrecord-ProDVD-ProBD-Clone 2.01.01a64 (x86_64-unknown-linux-gnu) Copyright (C) 1995-2009 Jörg Schilling
scsidev: '5,0,0'
scsibus: 5 target: 0 lun: 0
...
Driver flags : NO-CD DVD MMC-3 SWABAUDIO BURNFREE
Supported modes: PACKET SAO LAYER_JUMP
Mounted media class: DVD
Mounted media type: DVD+R
Disk Is not erasable
data type: standard
disk status: complete
session status: complete
BG format status: none
first track: 1
number of sessions: 154
first track in last sess: 154
last track in last sess: 154
Disk Is unrestricted
Disk type: DVD, HD-DVD or BD
Track Sess Type Start Addr End Addr Size
==============================================
1 1 Data 0 104879 104880
2 2 Data 106928 113871 6944
...
153 153 Data 1403424 1404223 800
154 154 Data 1406272 1416159 9888
Last session start address: 1406272
Last session leadout start address: 1416160
#
---------------------------------------------------
BD-R media causes cdrecord to complain
WARNING: Phys disk size 4452354 differs from rzone size 12219392! Prerecorded disk?
WARNING: Phys start: 25088 Phys end 4477441
This happens in both profile roles: BD-ROM and
BD-R. It does not happen with BD-RE media in
the profile role as BD-RE, but it happens as
BD-ROM. (BD-ROM profile reported by BD-ROM drive.)
Can it be that this is a misperception from
the BD specific reply of 51h READ DISC INFORMATION
as described in MMC-5 6.23.3.3.1 Format Code 00h:
byte 8 size 3 : Disc Type Identifier =
BDO for BD-ROM, BDW for BD-RE,
BDR for BD-R
byte 11 size 1 : Size/Class/Version
(no information available)
in comparison to the DVD specific reply as
described in 6.23.3.2.1 Format Code 00h:
byte 8 00h
byte 9 (MSB)--------------------------------------
byte 10 | End Physical Sector Number of Data Area |
byte 11 (LSB)--------------------------------------
'D' * (1 << 16) + 'R' * (1 << 8) + 1 = 4477441
+ 1 - 25088 = 4452354
These are the sizes cdrecord warns about.
With BD-RE in ROM drive as BD-ROM i see:
WARNING: Phys start: 25344 Phys end 4478722
'D' * (1 << 16) + 'W' * (1 << 8) + 2 = 4478722
A similar message appears with DVD-RAM
WARNING: Phys disk size 2314080 differs from rzone size 2236704! Prerecorded disk?
WARNING: Phys start: 200704 Phys end 2514783
...
Mounted media type: DVD-RAM
...
disk status: illegal
MMC-5 6.23.3.2.1 Format Code 00h (for DVD):
"The End Physical Sector Number of Data Area field specifies the last sector
of the user data in the last layer of the media. For DVD-RAM, the End
Physical Sector Number of Data Area is the PSN for the last spare sector of
the last zone."
So it seems normal, that DVD-RAM has differing
values here.
---------------------------------------------------
With a closed BD-R, i get from cdrecord
Mounted media type: BD-ROM
...
disk status: complete
session status: complete
...
1 1 Data 0 12219391 12219392
...
Last session leadout start address: 12219392
So far so good. But the drive tells two sizes:
52h READ TRACK INFORMATION reports 12219392
25h READ CAPACITY reports as last block 11217567
43h READ TOC/PMA/ATIP Form 0 reports 11217568
All 12219392 blocks are readable from media.
Nevertheless there is a better info about the
really written size. So i propose to put out an
additional minfo line with -ROM profiles.
Like:
Last session start address: 0
Last session leadout start address: 12219392
Read capacity: 11217568
---------------------------------------------------
A BD-R in a BD-ROM drive appears as "BD-ROM"
which is "incomplete/appendable":
Mounted media class: BD
Mounted media type: BD-ROM
Disk Is not erasable
disk status: incomplete/appendable
session status: empty
...
number of sessions: 5
...
4 4 Data 4379200 6595263 2216064
5 5 Blank 6595264 12219391 5624128
Last session start address: 4379200
Last session leadout start address: 6595264
This happens on a DVD-burner/BD-ROM combo drive
Vendor_info : 'HL-DT-ST'
Identifikation : 'BDDVDRW GGC-H20L'
Revision : '1.03'
with an appendable BD-R inserted.
I have no CD/DVD combo drive and cdrecord refuses
-minfo on my DVD-ROM drive. So i cannot test whether
this happens to appendable DVD media too if they
appear as DVD-ROM.
The status parameters are correct. But is it
consistent to show them with an alleged BD-ROM ?
Shouldn't it rather be:
disk status: complete
session status: complete
first track: 1
number of sessions: 4
first track in last sess: 4
last track in last sess: 4
...
number of sessions: 4
...
4 4 Data 4379200 6595263 2216064
Last session start address: 4379200
Last session leadout start address: 6595264
---------------------------------------------------
-minfo reports with overwriteable media (DVD+RW,
DVD-RAM, formatted DVD-RW, BD-RE) literally
what 51h READ DISC INFORMATION replies:
Disk Is erasable
...
disk status: complete
session status: complete
...
1 1 Data 0 2295103 2295104
Last session start address: 0
Last session leadout start address: 2295104
This complies with MMC but seems inconsistent
from the view of a burn willing user:
cdrecord -minfo refuses on read-only drives.
So it is obviously oriented to the write
capabilities and not so much to read capabilities
of the media.
There is no BLANK command for DVD+RW and one can
write them from scratch without any precautions
(at least from user view).
So shouldn't -minfo be rather like:
Disk Is not erasable
...
disk status: empty
session status: empty
...
1 1 Blank 0 2295103 2295104
Next writable address: 0
Remaining writable size: 2295104
---------------------------------------------------
Tested media:
CD-R blank, appendable, closed, data, audio
CD-RW blank, appendable, closed, data, audio
DVD+R blank, appendable, closed
DVD+RW formatted
DVD-R blank, closed
DVD-RW blank, appendable, restricted overwrite
DVD-RAM formatted
BD-R blank, appendable, appendable in BD-ROM drive,
closed
BD-RE formatted
If you want to see particular outputs, feel free
to ask.
---------------------------------------------------
Have a nice day :)
Thomas
--
To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [email protected]
with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [email protected]