Re: Feedback required for CritiqueBrainz's Moderation Interface

On 6/26/15, Roman Tsukanov <[email protected]> wrote:

> On screenshots that you linked there's a "Votes" column. Users can
vote on spam reports?

They are the votes on the associated revision, maybe I should change
the header to "Votes on revision".

> Don't know why moderators would need to edit reviews. I think only
author should be able to do that. Their name is associated with review
and it's not a wiki page.

I was thinking that maybe we could use this interface as a way to fix
issues like CB-150: http://tickets.musicbrainz.org/browse/CB-150

There was some discussion about it here:
http://chatlogs.musicbrainz.org/musicbrainz-devel/2015/2015-01/2015-01-13.html#T10-13-25-135366

So people could 'report' these reviews giving a reason like "F*** is
treated as markdown syntax", and then moderators could edit the review
to fix it.

> Function for deleting spam reports seems unnecessary. And I think that
some kind of logging system for admin actions should be a part of this
interface.

I am working on a logging interface (which I guess will be visible to
everyone - not just the admins.)

> Overview of all spam reports seems to be missing.

Sorry but I don't get what you mean? This interface is the overview, isn't it?

> We also need a way to ban/delete users.

Considering that this action will only be taken when all the reviews
of a user are spam, I think we should just delete the user account
(which will also remove all the associated reviews.)

I'll add this action to the interface.