Re: [mb-users] Where to add the recording date?

Am 2014-09-15 14:44, schrieb Lemire, Sebastien:
> Yeah I brought this up too when the places got added to MB. It makes no
> sense adding it everywhere, if there's a mistake editing is a major PIA.
Agreed.
> The way I see it though, if we'd have a single location, it can't really be
> at as begin and end date of the place-recording AR since there's many
> instances where we don't know the place (or not readily available at first)
> but we have the date. We can't use this AR without a place...
There is an [unknown] place. There are examples of "recorded at 
[unknown] (SOMEDATE)", e.g. 
https://musicbrainz.org/recording/2ab221c5-304c-4245-8a4b-72fb678e783f 
as well as "recorded by [unknown] (SOMEDATE)", e.g. 
https://musicbrainz.org/recording/e1453d17-8aca-4cde-a79e-8fd17f3a46a7 
in the database. Both are seldom used, with the former being a bit more 
popular.

All in all, I don't think that this is a strong point against 
standardising on hanging the date on the place AR.

Robbe