RE: Link Management

This discussion at W3C is probably relevant. 

http://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI.html

In other words, you can move your stuff, but it should still be where it
was.

D

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Robert Koberg
Sent: 15 September 2004 11:51
To: James Robertson
Cc: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [CMS] Link Management

James Robertson wrote:

>
>> To me, a redirect is an ugly hack. And to me, the CMS should build 
>> document relative links (as opposed to root relative) so a site can 
>> be dropped anywhere.
>>
>> This type of feature was one of most important when building our CMS. 
>> Since we focused on a storyboard metaphor, we started with the 
>> assumption that the site changes a great deal at least when starting 
>> -- build it, try it for usablity, rebuild based on feedback, rinse, 
>> lather, repeat...
>
>
> Rob,
>
> Relative URLs are a good thing, but solve a quite different
> problem to the one we're talking about.
>
> The situation that causes problems is when a file is moved
> from one section of the site to another. This might make the
> URL change as follows:
>
> www.site.com/about/background/ --> www.site.com/seminars/background/
>
> In this situation, external visitors who have bookmarked the first
> URL would get a page-not-found. This is where the CMS needs to
> automatically generate redirects (or rewriting, etc) when pages
> are moved in the site hierarchy.


This is a different problem than I thought we were discussing.

I thought we were discussing link management within the CMS (I discussed 
that in a different post or two). I also have posted why I felt relying 
on redirects for link management /in the CMS/ was not a good idea.

I guess the bookmarking problem would be better handled by a CMS that 
edits the live site directly and has the ability/knowledge to affect the 
webserver. I personally don't think a CMS should edit the live site 
directly without a development and QA stage, but that is a different topic.

best,
-Rob

>
> Cheers,
> James
>
> -------------------------
> James Robertson
> Step Two Designs Pty Ltd
> Knowledge Management / Content Management / Intranets
>
> http://www.steptwo.com.au/
> [email protected]
>

_______________________________________________
cms mailing list
[email protected]
Subscription controls:
http://lists.cms-forum.org/mailman/listinfo/cms
Netiquette FAQ and related CMS lists - [CMS-Forum], [CMS-Meta], [CMS-PR],
[CMS-Develop]
http://www.cmsreview.com/NetiquetteFAQ.html