Re: Relative paths in .desktop, .service files' Exec= lines

On 23 June 2016 at 19:54, Simon McVittie <[email protected]> wrote:
> On 23/06/16 17:53, Allison Lortie wrote:
>> On Mon, Jun 20, 2016, at 13:24, Simon McVittie wrote:

>> On the other hand, what we are doing here very much might break the
>> previously working behaviour of making symlinks from
>> /usr/share/applications into the user's home directory.
>
> Right, that's a valid concern.
>
>> On the other other hand, if we follow this all the way down the rabbit
>> hole, we may get into weird situations whereby we're canonicalising
>> symlinks in situations where /usr is a symlink to /mnt/usr or something
>> equally awful, in which case we might end up at the wrong result.
>
> Indeed. I specifically don't want to do that.
>
>> For
>> that reason, I think we should limit any resolution step here to direct
>> inspection of the desktop file in question for being a symlink, itself,
>> and not attempt a full canonicalisation.
>
> OK. So are you thinking of something like this pseudocode?
>
>     path = $HOME/Desktop/dconf-editor.desktop   # or something
>
>     data = load(path)
>     working_directory = data["Path"]
>     argv = split(data["Exec"])
>
>     if argv[0] is absolute:
>         chdir(working_directory)
>         execv(argv[0], argv)
>     else if argv[0] contains a path separator:
>         if lstat(path) says it's a symlink:
>             link_target = readlink(path)
>             # assume join() is syntax-only manipulation like
>             # Python os.path.join, and does not look at the disk
>             reference = join(dirname(path), link_target)

This is a bit fishy. Link target may be absolute or relative path.

You can (ab)use this to your advantage, too.

Typically the desktop symlink will be absolute to / and desktop file
linking as part of installation will be typically relative.

Thanks

Michal
_______________________________________________
xdg mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/xdg