Re: How does GNOME 3 compare to Windows 8?

--===============0169875995==
Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="4eecc745_5f5e7fd0_128"

--4eecc745_5f5e7fd0_128
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

I have in fact used Windows 8, and I've done some informal usability testing with both it and Gnome 3. Comparing Fedora to Windows 8, Windows 8 is definitely far easier to install. But once you pass that, things start to fall away. Gnome 3 takes a minute for people to figure out how to use the activities hot corner, and after they've done that, any user of Windows, Mac OS or a reasonable desktop environment should be pretty much at home, albeit they probably won't figure out how virtual desktops work if they were a windows user. Windows 8 is a bit trickier. While, from what I've seen, it's fantastic on a tablet, and it's possible that they could fix it before launch, as of right now, the model of interaction is broken for desktops. Metro apps hide most all non-essential action buttons (Add
  a stock in the stocks app, the address bar in the Metro version of IE) so that you have to right click to pull them up, which is completely arbitrary and unintuitive. Nobody I tested this w
 ith coul
d figure this out, with any amount of time, (I only know because I watched an hour-long BUILD conference video on Metro) and furthermore, some of the testers didn't even realize that the toggle-switches were toggle-switches, because they were overly minimalist. App switching was also hidden, and in 'legacy mode', most people had trouble finding applications, because the 'start' button took them to Metro. That said, most of legacy mode acted as normal. Essentially, Metro is tacked-on and not at all usable for people who don't have touch screens, and if we do see non-touchscreens start seeming "Broken", it might make sense, but honestly, I don't expect that'll happen. I think we're looking at another Vista here.

-- 
Chris Beiser

--4eecc745_5f5e7fd0_128
Content-Type: text/html; charset="utf-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable
Content-Disposition: inline


                <div>
                    I have in fact used Windows 8, and I've done some inf=
ormal usability testing with both it and Gnome 3. Comparing =46edora to W=
indows 8, Windows 8 is definitely far easier to install. But once you pas=
s that, things start to fall away. Gnome 3 takes a minute for people to f=
igure out how to use the activities hot corner, and after they've done th=
at, any user of Windows, Mac OS or a reasonable desktop environment shoul=
d be pretty much at home, albeit they probably won't figure out how virtu=
al desktops work if they were a windows user. Windows 8 is a bit trickier=
. While, from what I've seen, it's fantastic on a tablet, and it's possib=
le that they could fix it before launch, as of right now, the model of in=
teraction is broken for desktops. Metro apps hide most all non-essential =
action buttons (Add a stock in the stocks app, the address bar in the Met=
ro version of IE) so that you have to right click to pull them up, which =
is completely arbitrary and unintuitive. Nobody I tested this with could =
figure this out, with any amount of time, (I only know because I watched =
an hour-long BUILD conference video on Metro) and furthermore, some of th=
e testers didn't even realize that the toggle-switches were toggle-switch=
es, because they were overly minimalist. App switching was also hidden, a=
nd in 'legacy mode', most people had trouble finding applications, becaus=
e the 'start' button took them to Metro. That said, most of legacy mode a=
cted as normal. Essentially, Metro is tacked-on and not at all usable for=
 people who don't have touch screens, and if we do see non-touchscreens s=
tart seeming =22Broken=22, it might make sense, but honestly, I don't exp=
ect that'll happen. I think we're looking at another Vista here.</div><di=
v><br></div><div>--&nbsp;<br>Chris Beiser<br></div>
            
--4eecc745_5f5e7fd0_128--


--===============0169875995==
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

_______________________________________________
usability mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/usability

--===============0169875995==--