Re: Possible bug in new_filer.cpp

Gary Setter wrote:
> ----- Original Message ----- 
> From: "Peter Kümmel" <[email protected]>
> To: <[email protected]>
> Sent: Sunday, June 11, 2006 6:03 AM
> Subject: [aspell-devel] Possible bug in new_filer.cpp
> 
> 
>> While compiling aspell I get warnings in new_filter.cpp.
>>
>> Is the assignment in the if() really by design or is it
>> a typo and copy&paste error?
>>
>> When it should really be an assignment, why not move it
>> into the code block?
>> Just an idea.
>>
>> Peter
> <snip>
> Hi Peter,
> No, it is not a typo. The code only assigns ifilter if the its
> prerequisites are met. Also, the test is not for equality, but
> for a null result.  As an exercise, you could try eliminating the
> warning by moving this code
>         RET_ON_ERR_SET(ifilter->setup(config), bool, keep);
>         ifilter->handle = filter_handle.release();
>         if (!keep) {
>           ifilter.del();
>         } else {
>           filter.add_filter(ifilter.release());
>         }
> and this code
>         RET_ON_ERR_SET(ifilter->setup(config), bool, keep);
>         ifilter->handle = filter_handle.release();
>         if (!keep) {
>           ifilter.del();
>         } else {
>           filter.add_filter(ifilter.release());
>         }
> and this code
>         RET_ON_ERR_SET(ifilter->setup(config), bool, keep);
>         ifilter->handle = encoder_handle.release();
>         if (!keep) {
>           ifilter.del();
>         } else {
>           filter.add_filter(ifilter.release());
>         }
>       }
> 
> into a function which takes as parameters f->decoder(),
> decoder_handle vs f->filter(), filter_handle vs f->encoder(),
> encoder_handle.  ifilter could be local to that function, I
> suspect.

Thanks for the explanation, and sorry for have questioned
the correctness of the aspell code, but this has looked
so like C that I've wondered about...

> I'm not in  the loop, but did you submit your changes to the
> sourceforge project?

No, I've only subscribed to the list.

> Kevin,
> Are we close to closing down the win-32 port ghetto and making
> aspell and Linux/windows application?
> Best regards,
> Gary

That would be fine, we use aspell in LyX and it would be much
more comfortable not to host there the make files.

Peter