Re: Re: Telnetd Vulnerability Report

Who uses telnet anyway? It's deprecated. Everyone uses ssh for any kind of =
remote access.


On Tuesday, February 24th, 2026 at 7:51 AM, Justin Swartz <justin.=
[email protected]> wrote:

> Greetings,
>=20
> I have been reviewing the recent vulnerability report by Ron Ben Yizhak =
regarding CREDENTIALS_DIRECTORY, as well as commit 4db2f19f which =
introduces unsetenv("CREDENTIALS_DIRECTORY") to address the problem.
>=20
> After becoming aware of CVE-2026-24061 (telnetd in GNU Inetutils through =
2.7 allows remote authentication bypass via a "-f root" value for the USER =
environment variable), I was curious to find out whether there'd also been =
a potential regression of CVE-1999-0073, described as: telnet allows a =
remote client to specify environment variables including LD_LIBRARY_PATH, =
allowing an attacker to bypass the normal system libraries and gain root =
access. I can confirm that this is still an issue 27 years later, despite =
attempts at blacklisting environment variables by prefix or full name.
>=20
> The problem stems from telnetd executing /bin/login in a root-to-root =
context, which means that AT_SECURE is set to 0 by the kernel in the =
process's auxiliary vector. When AT_SECURE holds a positive value, it =
informs the dynamic linker (ld-linux.so) and libc to enter a =
"secure-execution mode" where a bunch of interesting environment variables =
are discarded or, at least, defanged if present. In other words, the =
responsibility is on telnetd itself to ensure that none of those =
potentially interesting, and attacker controlled, variables make their way =
to /bin/login.
>=20
> While using unsetenv() negates a user's ability to exploit the login.=
noauth vector, the possibility still exists for the inclusion of variables =
of interest to GNU gettext (such as OUTPUT_CHARSET or LANGUAGE) and glibc =
(such as GCONV_PATH) via the telnet protocol itself.
>=20
> For example, by injecting OUTPUT_CHARSET and LANGUAGE, an attacker can =
persuade gettext that a character set conversion is necessary. This forces =
gettext to call libc's iconv_open(), and because AT_SECURE is 0, =
iconv_open() will use an injected GCONV_PATH in its quest for a =
gconv-modules file. Assuming the attacker already has a local unprivileged =
account, or at least a means of uploading files to the host (and knowing =
the location of the uploaded files), a custom gconv-modules file will allow=
 arbitrary shared objects to be loaded soon after /bin/login attempts to =
print a localized prompt.
>=20
> For proof of concept, I've declared a broad selection of LANGUAGE codes =
for the best chance of matching an installed locale. An attacker with local=
 access could simply determine what's actually installed and select only =
one that doesn't match the system's default locale instead. Similarly, =
OUTPUT_CHARSET has been chosen as a deliberate mismatch against the very =
common choice of UTF-8:
>=20
>   abuser-Ul9Lf3GqV0Q6qt9UHii4l/[email protected]:~$ ls -al .gconv
>   total 184
>   drwxr-xr-x 2 abuser abuser   4096 Jan  1  1970 .
>   drwxr-x--- 5 abuser abuser  36864 Jan  1  1970 ..
>   -rw-r--r-- 1 abuser abuser    256 Jan  1  1970 gconv-modules
>   -rw-r--r-- 1 abuser abuser  15568 Jan  1  1970 libcash2trash.so
>=20
>=20
>   abuser-Ul9Lf3GqV0Q6qt9UHii4l/[email protected]:~$ telnet -l abuser
>   telnet> environ define GCONV_PATH /home/abuser/.gconv
>   telnet> environ export GCONV_PATH
>   telnet> environ define LANGUAGE fr:de:es:it:pt:nl:sv:pl:uk:ru:zh_CN:ko:=
ja
>   telnet> environ export LANGUAGE
>   telnet> environ define OUTPUT_CHARSET ISO-8859-1
>   telnet> environ export OUTPUT_CHARSET
>   telnet> open 127.0.0.1
>   Trying 127.0.0.1...
>   Connected to 127.0.0.1.
>   Escape character is '^]'.
>=20
>   Linux (localhost) (pts/6)
>=20
>   Connection closed by foreign host.
>=20
>=20
>   abuser-Ul9Lf3GqV0Q6qt9UHii4l/[email protected]:~$ ls -al .gconv
>   total 184
>   drwxr-xr-x 2 abuser abuser   4096 Jan  1  1970 .
>   drwxr-x--- 5 abuser abuser  36864 Jan  1  1970 ..
>   -rw-r--r-- 1 abuser abuser    256 Jan  1  1970 gconv-modules
>   -rw-r--r-- 1 abuser abuser  15568 Jan  1  1970 libcash2trash.so
>   -rwsr-sr-x 1 root   root   125640 Jan  1  1970 trash
>=20
>=20
>   abuser-Ul9Lf3GqV0Q6qt9UHii4l/[email protected]:~$ .gconv/trash -p
>   # id
>   uid=3D1001(abuser) gid=3D1002(abuser) euid=3D0(root) egid=3D0(root) =
groups=3D0(root),1002(abuser)
>=20
>=20
> Once the telnet connection opens, /bin/login tries to print the localized=
 prompt but gettext recognizes the encoding mismatch and calls iconv_open()=
 to parse the gconv-modules file in the directory referenced by the =
injected path before loading the shared object that turns cash ($) to trash=
 (#). The connection drops because I included a call to exit() once the =
payload has executed. As illustrated above, the payload effectively asserts=
 root privilege and makes a copy of /bin/sh with SUID/SGID permissions. =
Note that no authentication via telnetd was required, nor performed, for =
this privilege escalation trick to occur. Also note that this is just one =
of many possible methods that may be used to exploit this condition.
>=20
> In my opinion, to fix this issue and finally put the ghost of =
CVE-1999-0073 to rest: telnetd must drop the blacklist approach and adopt =
the OpenSSH AcceptEnv-style approach suggested by Simon Josefsson [1], =
which amounts to preparing a brand new environment for /bin/login based on =
a strict whitelist of variables names considered to be "safe", and perhaps =
a healthy dose of input sanitization for their respective values.
>=20
> In terms of the CVE that Ron Ben Yizhak had asked about earlier in the =
thread: I think it might make the most sense to co-ordinate a single CVE =
for "Improper environment sanitization in telnetd" that comprehensively =
covers both the CREDENTIALS_DIRECTORY vector and this dynamic linker escape=
.
>=20
> I'm happy to share the intentionally redacted payload privately with the =
maintainers should any help be required to reproduce the proof of concept.
>=20
> Regards,
> Justin
>=20
> ---
>=20
> [1] https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-inetutils/2026-02/msg00002.=
html
>