Re: FYI: fix-bootstrap-translation-download-on-darwin

On Sep 6, 2007, at 2:19 PM, Ralf Wildenhues wrote:
> Hi Gary,

Hallo Ralf,

> Gary V. Vaughan <gary <at> gnu.org> writes:
>>
>>   	Work around a bug in darwin's awk:
>
>>   	(func_get_translations): The first awk script mangles the last
>>   	entry passed to it for at least the awk implementation shipped
>>   	with Darwin 8.10.1.  Capture $3 into a variable too to work-
>>   	around that problem.
>
> Could you be bothered to explain what this bug does?  I don't quite
> understand from the patch nor the description.  Should it be listed
> in the Autoconf shell portability section?

Sure.

$ cat in
cs:1.4o:../PO-files
da:1.4o:../PO-files
de:1.4o:../PO-files
el:1.4n:../PO-files
el:1.4o:../PO-files
fr:1.4o:../PO-files


# Before the patch (note the last line of output):

$ cat in | /opt/local/bin/gawk -F: '
 >   { if (lang && $1 != lang) print lang, ver, $3 }
 >   { lang = $1; ver = $2 }
 >   END { if (lang) print lang, ver, $3 }'
cs 1.4o ../PO-files
da 1.4o ../PO-files
de 1.4o ../PO-files
el 1.4o ../PO-files
fr 1.4o ../PO-files
$ cat in | /usr/bin/awk -F: '
 >   { if (lang && $1 != lang) print lang, ver, $3 }
 >   { lang = $1; ver = $2 }
 >   END { if (lang) print lang, ver, $3 }'
cs 1.4o ../PO-files
da 1.4o ../PO-files
de 1.4o ../PO-files
el 1.4o ../PO-files
fr 1.4o


# After the patch:

$ cat in | /opt/local/bin/gawk -F: '
 >   { if (lang && $1 != lang) print lang, ver, subdir }
 >   { lang = $1; ver = $2; subdir = $3 }
 >   END { if (lang) print lang, ver, subdir }'
cs 1.4o ../PO-files
da 1.4o ../PO-files
de 1.4o ../PO-files
el 1.4o ../PO-files
fr 1.4o ../PO-files
$ cat in | /usr/bin/awk -F: '
 >   { if (lang && $1 != lang) print lang, ver, subdir }
 >   { lang = $1; ver = $2; subdir = $3 }
 >   END { if (lang) print lang, ver, subdir }'
cs 1.4o ../PO-files
da 1.4o ../PO-files
de 1.4o ../PO-files
el 1.4o ../PO-files
fr 1.4o ../PO-files

It appears that only gawk saves $3 from the last input line for use  
in the END clause, where darwin awk (maybe others too, I haven't  
looked elsewhere) discards it.

Cheers,
	Gary
-- 
   ())_.              Email me: [email protected]
   ( '/           Read my blog: http://blog.azazil.net
   / )=         ...and my book: http://sources.redhat.com/autobook
`(_~)_      Join my AGLOCO Network: http://www.agloco.com/r/BBBS7912

_______________________________________________
M4-patches mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/m4-patches