Re: Feature request (with patch)

[email protected] (Karl Berry) Mon, 10 Sep 2012 22:09:01 GMT
Newsgroups gmane.comp.gnu.rcs
Message-ID <[email protected]>
    reaction is to regretfully point out that the comma-v syntax is frozen

As someone who still uses RCS daily on multiple machines, and is highly
concerned about compatibility, I can still say that this particular
change seems unproblematic to me.  If I'm understanding it right.

If a ,v file has extra information, and GNU RCS simply preserves it,
that's not going to hurt any existing use of RCS -- no one else would
even know about it.  Likewise, if GNU RCS adds new information to a ,v
given some new option or whatever, that's also not going to hurt any
existing use, because it's explicitly asked for.

The problem would be with any existing ,v files getting munged in some
way merely when a new version of RCS does a normal operation.  As I
recall, the previous discussion was along those lines.

FWIW ...

karl