Re: bug report in command ( ps -ef | grep "myTask" | grep -v "grep" | wc -l )

OSK Lu Jun wrote:
> To: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
> To whom it may concern

Please do not cross post to so many unrelated groups.  Especially when
asking for help it is more appropriate to pick a specific forum.  If a
particular one does not produce an answer is is okay to try a
different one.

> are alive. In bash file I use the COMMAND
> (  PROCESS_NUM=`ps -ef | grep  "myTask" | grep -v "grep" | wc -l` )
> to judge the alive  status of my executable programs.

I see that type of thing frequently, where users use grep once and
then again to remove the grep itself from the process listing.  That
is not needed.  It is better written differently.  It is better to
avoid the need at all.

1. It is better written different.  The '-f' option of ps produces a
   full listing.  But this is the cause of grep showing up in the list
   and users wanting to remove the grep.  So don't use the -f option.
   Use only the -e option and only look at the program name.  I prefer
   awk for this task.

     ps -u root -e | awk '$NF=="myTask"'

2. Better to avoid this type of test at all.  It is easy to be fooled
   by processes that happen to be running with the same name.
   Restricting to just the root user processes as in the above example
   with '-u root' helps but I think still better to avoid.  Better to
   have the process write its PID in a file and to check that pid for
   being alive in the system.

Bob


_______________________________________________
[email protected]
http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/bug-gnu-utils