Re: commit: framework/MIME MIME.php framework/MIME/MIME Part.php

Quoting Michael M Slusarz <[email protected]>:

>>> Log:
>>> A better random ID generator. Don't create boundary string until needed.
>>
>> If this is Horde 4/PHP 5 only, how about using Horde_Support_Uuid?
>
> UUIDs are not preferable for several reasons:
> 1. They are overly long - for most MIME operations (i.e. boundaries,  
> Message-IDs), the IDs only need to be unique within each message or,  
> in the case of Message-IDs, unique on that particular system; since  
> we later append system information to the random ID, there is no  
> need for those message-ID random strings to be globally unique.  We  
> don't need a 36-character long string.
> 2. UUIDs waste a lot of space, important when the information will  
> be in transport.  UUIDs are only in hex, so for each byte we are  
> only using 16/127 of the possible ASCII values (well, less than 127  
> because some of those are control characters, but for sake of  
> argument...).  The MIME IDs use 36/127 so we can pack more unique  
> randomness into a smaller string.  We theoretically could pack even  
> more randomness by adding other printable characters ("!@#%^&",  
> etc.) into the string, but for sake of ease of creation, 36 chars  
> should be fine.

Works for me. If this is something we might want in other places, I'd  
advocate a Horde_Support lib for it.

-chuck

--
To unsubscribe, mail: [email protected]