RE: [Avalon4:VOTE] Context Consensus

"Leo Sutic" <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.comp.jakarta.avalon.apps.devel,gmane.comp.jakarta.avalon.devel
Message-ID <000801c2a375$d03db000$0801a8c0@Lagrange>
> From: Paul Hammant [mailto:[email protected]] 
>
> >    WARNING: A component that specifies this requirement will not
> >             be as portable as one that doesn't. Few containers
> >             support it. It is therefore discouraged for components
> >             to require a castable context.

> If this is a phrase for the future (when Phoenix has been 
> replaced by UberContainer),

*No.* 

The Über is a big unknown at the moment. Will it be A4 compliant?
Will it be so via a compatibility layer? Will it have A5 features?
What will those be? And so on... Once the Über has been created, 
and we have nailed down the different profiles (if any), I expect 
this contract to change. But that's a bit in the future, thus
a warning based on the current state of Avalon is valid.

If the Über *does* have very good support for castable contexts, 
or if we get such features in many containers, we can just remove the
warning. If not, we let it remain.

> Otherwise +1

Noted your +1. I hope I answered your question and that you are
satisfied with the reply.

/LS
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.