Re: Upgrading from Turbine 2.3.3 to 5.0

Georg,
	Thank you so much for the information!  I have gotten started on =
building the default project.  I am having proxy issues, but I=E2=80=99m =
getting help with that and will hopefully be able to generate the =
project soon.

Thanks!
Michele

> On Jul 10, 2023, at 4:25 AM, Georg Kallidis =
<[email protected]> wrote:
>=20
> Hello Michele,
>=20
> just a first thought. You may checkout the Turbine archetype (see =
below)=20
> and get first a running Turbine 5 default project and proceed from =
there=20
> ...=20
>=20
> If you did achieve this first step successfully (you need Java 8 and =
maven=20
> 3.x at least) update step-by-step with your custom settings =
(templates,=20
> and conf-folder). Compare this new settings with your old and upgrade =
step=20
> by step either in the new or in the old place.=20
>=20
> I would recommend to update in the new project settings, that is to=20
> identify your customizations (services/templates/actions) and add to =
the=20
> newly generated project.=20
> You may easily restart again by regenerating it again .. On the other =
side=20
> if you decide upgrading your old settings in-place - you have to =
consider=20
> more intricaties, as described in the migration pages you mentioned,=20=

> update to TurbineYaafiComponentService, check=20
> WEB-INF/conf/turbine-classic-pipeline.xml and all the main Turbine=20
> configuration files in Web-INF/conf. E.g. some packages have changed, =
most=20
> importantly e.g.=20
> =
services.RunDataService.default.parameter.parser=3Dorg.apache.fulcrum.pars=
er.DefaultParameterParser,=20
> of course you need the new pom.xml ..
>=20
>=20
> A description of how to start with Turbine archetype is described  in =
the=20
> Turbine project pages, =
https://turbine.apache.org/turbine-concepts.html#.
>=20
>=20
> mvn archetype:generate
>=20
> then filtering with=20
>=20
> org.apache.turbine:turbine-webapp-5.0
> or
> org.apache.turbine:
>=20
> and select e.g.
>=20
> remote: org.apache.turbine:turbine-webapp-5.0
>=20
> Read also=20
> =
https://github.com/apache/turbine-archetypes/blob/master/src/main/resource=
s/archetype-resources/docs/README.md=20
> or  https://github.com/apache/turbine-archetypes/tree/5.0-1.0.3.
>=20
> You need to upgrade all component versions you mentioned
>=20
>                 Turbine 2.3.3
>                 Maven 1.1
>                 Torque 3.3
>                 Velocity 1.5
>=20
> You need at least Java 8, Maven 3.5. Turbine 5 uses Torque 4 and =
Velocity=20
> 2.0.
>=20
> Last but not least, you may take advantage from the fact that all old=20=

> subversion code is migrated to git, that is you could easily and =
quickly=20
> compare and checkout all versions in github!
>=20
> https://github.com/apache/turbine-core=20
>=20
> For further background use https://github.com/apache/turbine-build to =
get=20
> an overview of all the components currently supported.
>=20
> If you need further assistance, ask here again providing more =
information.
>=20
>=20
> Thanks and good luck!
>=20
>=20
> Best regards,=20
>=20
> Georg
>=20
>=20
>=20
> Von:    Michele Rabanal <[email protected]>
> An:     [email protected]
> Datum:  07.07.2023 22:53
> Betreff:        Upgrading from Turbine 2.3.3 to 5.0
>=20
>=20
>=20
> Hello!
>=20
> I am an applications developer on the Turbine framework.  Many years =
ago I=20
> upgraded Turbine from 2.2 to 2.3.=20
> For security reasons, I am being asked to upgrade Turbine again.  I=20
> understand that I should be on Turbine 5.0, but
> I'm not clear on exactly how to begin!=20
>=20
> I have tried to follow=20
> =
https://turbine.apache.org/turbine/turbine-5-0/howto/migrate-from-2_3-howt=
o.html=20
> <
> =
https://turbine.apache.org/turbine/turbine-5-0/howto/migrate-from-2_3-howt=
o.html
>> , but I've gotten
> nowhere and really just need more basic instructions.=20
>=20
> Questions:
> 1) Should I do an actual in-place upgrade or should I build a new=20
> framework and then move my current project over into it?
>=20
> 2) Do I need to use a more current version of Maven?  And if so, what =
is=20
> the best way to get my current project
>   into that new Maven structure?  and into the new Turbine structure?
>=20
> I would appreciate any help!  I've tried many different approaches, =
but=20
> cannot figure this out. Installing/upgrading=20
> software is not my main role!  If there are documents with more =
details,=20
> that would be great.=20
>=20
> Here's the path of my current project:
>=20
> =
.maven/cache/maven-turbine-plugin-1.3/plugin-resources/flavor/turbine-2.3.=
3/inventory
>=20
>    I believe these are the components/versions I'm using:
>                 Turbine 2.3.3
>                 Maven 1.1
>                 Torque 3.3
>                 Velocity 1.5
>=20
> Thanks so much!
>=20