Re: [Fwd: Re: [JPackage-discuss] Re: Status of classpathx-mail, classpath-inetlib, gnu-crypto]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Fernando Nasser wrote:
>>> > One new detail: classpathx-mail cannot be used as a drop-in 
>>> replacement
>>> > for javamail due to its dependency on inetlib. Sorry Ville, I am 
>>> not sure I understood.  Wouldn't it be that as long as someone has 
>>> the inetlib package then they could install classpathx-mail as a 
>>> replacement for javamail?
>>
>> No, merely installing inetlib is not enough (and it's already taken 
>> care
>> of with the rpm dependency).  It needs to be included in CLASSPATH one
>> way or another too when using classpathx-mail.
>
> We need to get this solved so we can get javamail  (and jaf) on Fedora 
> as
> replacements for the non-open source ones.
>
> Would it be possible to have a procedure of regularly importing 
> inetlib sources and changing the packages with a script so we have a 
> self contained javamail?
>
> It would still be using inetlib, so not duplicating development.  It 
> would only give us a little bit of work here and there.  I believe 
> that with CVS and vendor branch imports we can actually do this 
> conversion only once (except for new files).

When you say a "self-contained" javamail, you mean packaging all the 
classes needed at runtime into one JAR file? This would include a JSSE 
implementation, etc, as specified in the inetlib INSTALL file. It would 
get messy, especially when people wanted to mix and match with 
different VMs, library versions, etc.

A better solution would be to patch the manifest in the various jar 
files (gnumail.jar, gnumail-providers.jar, activation.jar, inetlib.jar) 
- - since the dependency jars have been installed to absolute locations 
by the package manager, you can simply insert a Class-Path entry in the 
manifest containing these absolute locations, and Java will locate the 
dependencies without the user having to specify a classpath explicitly.
- -- 
Chris Burdess
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.4 (Darwin)

iD8DBQFBG+G+6dl1DEqHgrgRAn5OAKCGUW83iw0ZEz0INTkSS7ECfjp6TACeP4Ux
erNMVsy6myfnxXZp6DoEQnk=
=f15y
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----