Re: ORM help

Hi Patrick,

As far as I know collections with filters cannot be used to add objects
to those collections.
If you think about it, in your schema, Helmas ORM has no way of knowing
that in order to associate a tag to a node, it has to add the tags id to
the TAGS column of that node (I'm guessing its a comma seperated list?)
I think its only working because the assoication is made "in memory" in
helmas object cache and so disappears once you restart the app and if
you look in the sql db table TAGS, there is no new entry in the TAGS
column.

To do many-to-many relations you'd normally use a "mapping" table in the
sql db that has a column for each of the id's of the tables (node amd
tag) that you are associating with each other.
Theres a handy article about this on the helma site in:
http://helma.org/docs/examples/subscriptions/

Having said that, actually I have in the past done exactly what your
schema does but using "read-only" filtered collections and inserting
objects id's "manually" into the relevant property (eg. your TAGS column
in NODES table) where they are kept as a comma sperated list. However I
found this to be a real pain and not really worth the trouble vs just
creating a mapping table.

Maks.

> -----Original Message-----
> From: [email protected] 
> [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Patrick Lee
> Sent: Wednesday, 26 March 2008 12:36
> To: Helma User Mailing List
> Subject: [Helma-user] ORM help
> 
> Hi,
> 
> I'm trying to get my head around the ORM in Helma. Best way 
> to explain is probably to show what I have. There's a 
> prototype called "Node" and one called "Tag" each Node can 
> have many tags associated to it and each tag can be 
> associated to many Nodes.
> 
> Node/type.properties includes this:
> 
> tag_ids              = TAGS
> tags                 = collection(Tag)
> tags.accessname      = TITLE_SHORT
> tags.filter          = TAG.ID IN (${NODE.TAGS})
> 
> Tag/type.properties includes this:
> 
> nodes = collection(Node)
> nodes.filter.additionalTables = TAG
> nodes.filter = TAG.ID = ${ID} AND FIND_IN_SET(TAG.ID, NODE.TAGS)
> 
> I also have all the tags on the root like so:
> Root/type.properties:
> tags                  = collection(Tag)
> tags.accessname       = TITLE_SHORT
> 
> The problem I'm having is that whilst I seem to be able to 
> add a Tag to a Node (eg, this.tags.add(new Node())) and 
> access them via the URL, every time open the URL for a Node, 
> this.tags.list() is empty.
> 
> Any clues? Have I got something wrong here?
> _______________________________________________
> Helma-user mailing list
> [email protected]
> http://helma.org/mailman/listinfo/helma-user
>