why not merge that eclipse-perspective-lookalike and NB3.6-explorer tree ?

[email protected] (Peter Buckenleib)
Newsgroups gmane.comp.java.netbeans.user-interface
Message-ID <[email protected]>
Hi NB-Community,

i know it's probably too late for the upcoming release, but i really 
can't resist ....

I started with NB3.4 and currently I'm working with NB3.6, and i really 
love it. I had to spend some time using eclipse2.1, and i learned to 
hate it's gui. Now i had some time to check the new NB4.0 and ....

When i imported my current project into NB4 i was almost shocked by 
that flat unstructured endless list of packages that reminded me of the 
ugly "java perspective" of eclipse. Why did you quit that wonderfull 
tree of NB3.6 ?
i can't believe it would skip the new project-oriented design (which is 
realy GREAT) if you would display packages in a tree combining 
path-elements to nodes instead of that flat list. It would be much 
easier to navigate and find what your looking for and use much less 
space since nodes that are currently of no interest can be collapsed, 
such hiding all the packages below that chosen level. Splitting a 
project that has grown too large into dependent sub-projects could help 
a little bit, but is just a kind of workaround.

mounting jars and other libs to (undeletable) special nodes of a project  
(those that show up on the left side of the project properties dialog) 
would be much easier and much more intuitive too, compared to dialogs 
with lots of tabs, where you have to know exactly what feature is in 
what tab of what dialog. Please do not imitate that ugly feature of 
eclipse too.

the new refacturing-features are the part of nb4 i like most of all. one 
argument less for the eclipse-fanatics (grin), also there is still a 
lot of work to do. You are on the right way, PLEASE go on!
 
I think it's a bad idea to imitate the ugly eclipse-perspectives to make 
eclipse users work with netbeans. cvs integration, crossreferencing and 
refacturing are the features that realy count.
So why does NB/Sun try to imitate the bad parts of eclipse first? 
Perhaps you get a few eclipse-users to switch to netbeans and get 
current netbeans(3.6)-users to switch to xy the same time.

Well let's see what the future will be.

regards

Peter
-- 
Peter Buckenleib
Am Europakanal 8
91056 Erlangen

Tel: 09131 992234
Fax: 09131 791045

Mail: [email protected]
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.