Re: TomEE does not launch on Java 24

------ANZHZVKZUCGMHAK1CN5LAME4TMXB8M
Content-Type: text/plain;
 charset=utf-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Yep, I think, I already see the issue=2E I will take a look :-)

Am 13=2E Juli 2025 10:30:39 MESZ schrieb Wolfgang Knauf <wolfgang=2Eknauf@=
gmx=2Ede=2EINVALID>:
>I reopened https://issues=2Eapache=2Eorg/jira/browse/TOMEE-4474 and attac=
hed a reproducer=2E
>
>I am not sure whether it is really related to Java 24, but my sample work=
s with Java 17 and fails with 24=2E If my conclusion is not correct, I can =
create a new one=2E
>
>Gr=C3=BC=C3=9Fe
>
>Wolfgang
>
>Am 12=2E07=2E25 um 20:31 schrieb Richard Zowalla:
>> If that still doesn't work, maybe you could put up a simple reproducer =
project, which mimics your case and we can have a look=2E
>>=20
>> Gru=C3=9F
>> Richard
>>=20
>> On 2025/07/12 18:23:08 Richard Zowalla wrote:
>>> I see=2E You can check out TomEE main, run a mvn clean install with sk=
ipped test=2E It only needs a JDK 17=2E
>>>=20
>>> That should install everything you need locally, so you can just use i=
t as usual=2E
>>>=20
>>> Regarding browser download: yeah, might be an ASF INFRA restriction :-=
)
>>>=20
>>> Gru=C3=9F
>>> Richard
>>>=20
>>> Am 12=2E Juli 2025 19:15:27 MESZ schrieb Wolfgang Knauf <wolfgang=2Ekn=
auf@gmx=2Ede=2EINVALID>:
>>>> Well, this did not work for me (the project where I want to test the =
new version uses ShrinkWrap resolver to download the container and I did no=
t manage to make it use the snapshot repository), but I found out that I ca=
n configure the direct URL to the tomee artifact in the project=2E
>>>> But this resulted in the same error=2E
>>>>=20
>>>> Or is it related to me not using the arquillian container artifact fr=
om "https://repository=2Eapache=2Eorg/content/groups/snapshots/org/apache/t=
omee/arquillian-tomee-remote/10=2E1=2E1-SNAPSHOT/"?
>>>>=20
>>>> About not being able to download files by browser: firefox console re=
ports this error:
>>>>=20
>>>> Das Herunterladen von "https://repository=2Eapache=2Eorg/content/grou=
ps/snapshots/org/apache/tomee/apache-tomee/10=2E1=2E1-SNAPSHOT/apache-tomee=
-10=2E1=2E1-20250712=2E035301-33-webprofile=2Ezip" wurde blockiert, weil f=
=C3=BCr den ausl=C3=B6senden iframe das sandbox-Attribut gesetzt ist=2E
>>>>=20
>>>> So it seems it is intended to block manual downloads?
>>>>=20
>>>> Best regards
>>>>=20
>>>> Wolfgang
>>>>=20
>>>>=20
>>>> Am 12=2E07=2E25 um 13:53 schrieb Richard Zowalla:
>>>>> Hi Wolfgang,
>>>>>=20
>>>>> You could try to configure the pluginRepository / repository into yo=
ur local Maven POM for testing the snapshots:
>>>>>=20
>>>>> <repositories>
>>>>>     <repository>
>>>>>       <id>apache</id>
>>>>>       <url>https://repository=2Eapache=2Eorg/snapshots/</url>
>>>>>       <releases>
>>>>>         <enabled>false</enabled>
>>>>>       </releases>
>>>>>       <snapshots>
>>>>>         <enabled>true</enabled>
>>>>>       </snapshots>
>>>>>     </repository>
>>>>> </repositories>
>>>>>=20
>>>>> You can reference the snapshot directly in your build afterwards=2E =
Similar can be done for <pluginRepository>=2E
>>>>>=20
>>>>> Gru=C3=9F
>>>>> Richard
>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Am 12=2E07=2E2025 um 11:14 schrieb Wolfgang Knauf <wolfgang=2Eknauf=
@gmx=2Ede=2EINVALID>:
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> There might be a problem with snapshot "apache-tomee-10=2E1=2E1-202=
50712=2E035301-33-webprofile=2Ezip"
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> (by the way: I cannot click the download links in a browser, had to=
 use "wget" to download it=2E Tried two different browsers and two OS)
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> I tested it with an arquillian project, where the tomee container i=
s pulled from maven and managed by "org=2Eapache=2Etomee:arquillian-tomee-r=
emote", so I had to replace the 10=2E1=2E0 version in my local maven reposi=
tory with the snapshot (replaced "C:\Users\MYUSERNAME\=2Em2\repository\org\=
apache\tomee\apache-tomee\10=2E1=2E0\apache-tomee-10=2E1=2E0-webprofile=2Ez=
ip" with snapshot file and renamed directory "apache-tomee-webprofile-10=2E=
1=2E1-SNAPSHOT" to "apache-tomee-webprofile-10=2E1=2E0" in zip)=2E
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Attached is the output of a maven run using Java 24=2E At some poin=
t, it starts printing thousands of errors:
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> java=2Eutil=2Econcurrent=2EExecutionException: java=2Elang=2EIllega=
lArgumentException: can't parse argument number:
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Eutil=2Econcurrent=2EFutureTask=2Ereport(Futu=
reTask=2Ejava:124)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Eutil=2Econcurrent=2EFutureTask=2Eget(FutureT=
ask=2Ejava:193)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eutil=2EMemoizer=2Ecompute(Memoizer=2Ej=
ava:63)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eutil=2ELogger=2EformatMessage(Logger=
=2Ejava:398)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eutil=2ELogger=2Ewarning(Logger=2Ejava:=
643)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecurityServ=
ice=2EisCallerAuthorized(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:398)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esingleton=2ESingletonContainer=
=2Einvoke(SingletonContainer=2Ejava:192)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Eivm=2EEjbHomeProxyHandler=2Ecre=
ate(EjbHomeProxyHandler=2Ejava:343)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Eivm=2EEjbHomeProxyHandler=2E_in=
voke(EjbHomeProxyHandler=2Ejava:196)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Eivm=2EBaseEjbProxyHandler=2Einv=
oke(BaseEjbProxyHandler=2Ejava:349)
>>>>>> 	at jdk=2Eproxy3/jdk=2Eproxy3=2E$Proxy30=2Ecreate(Unknown Source)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Eivm=2Enaming=2EBusinessRemoteRe=
ference=2EgetObject(BusinessRemoteReference=2Ejava:36)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Eivm=2Enaming=2EIvmContext=2Eloo=
kup(IvmContext=2Ejava:186)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Eejbd=2EJndiRequestHandler=2Ed=
oLookup(JndiRequestHandler=2Ejava:261)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Eejbd=2EJndiRequestHandler=2Ep=
rocessResponse(JndiRequestHandler=2Ejava:174)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Eejbd=2EEjbDaemon=2EprocessJnd=
iResponse(EjbDaemon=2Ejava:380)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Eejbd=2EEjbDaemon=2Eservice(Ej=
bDaemon=2Ejava:282)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Eejbd=2EEjbServer=2Eservice(Ej=
bServer=2Ejava:104)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eserver=2Ehttpd=2EServerServlet=2Eservi=
ce(ServerServlet=2Ejava:60)
>>>>>> 	at jakarta=2Eservlet=2Ehttp=2EHttpServlet=2Eservice(HttpServlet=2E=
java:658)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EApplicationFilterChain=2Einter=
nalDoFilter(ApplicationFilterChain=2Ejava:195)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EApplicationFilterChain=2EdoFil=
ter(ApplicationFilterChain=2Ejava:140)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EStandardWrapperValve=2Einvoke(=
StandardWrapperValve=2Ejava:167)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EStandardContextValve=2Einvoke(=
StandardContextValve=2Ejava:90)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2EOpenEJBValve=2Einvoke(OpenEJB=
Valve=2Ejava:45)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EStandardHostValve=2Einvoke(Sta=
ndardHostValve=2Ejava:116)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Evalves=2EErrorReportValve=2Einvoke(Er=
rorReportValve=2Ejava:93)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2EOpenEJBSecurityListener$Reque=
stCapturer=2Einvoke(OpenEJBSecurityListener=2Ejava:97)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Evalves=2EAbstractAccessLogValve=2Einv=
oke(AbstractAccessLogValve=2Ejava:666)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Ecore=2EStandardEngineValve=2Einvoke(S=
tandardEngineValve=2Ejava:74)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Econnector=2ECoyoteAdapter=2Eservice(C=
oyoteAdapter=2Ejava:344)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecoyote=2Ehttp11=2EHttp11Processor=2Eservice(Http=
11Processor=2Ejava:398)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecoyote=2EAbstractProcessorLight=2Eprocess(Abstra=
ctProcessorLight=2Ejava:63)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Ecoyote=2EAbstractProtocol$ConnectionHandler=2Epr=
ocess(AbstractProtocol=2Ejava:903)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomcat=2Eutil=2Enet=2ENioEndpoint$SocketProcesso=
r=2EdoRun(NioEndpoint=2Ejava:1769)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomcat=2Eutil=2Enet=2ESocketProcessorBase=2Erun(=
SocketProcessorBase=2Ejava:52)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomcat=2Eutil=2Ethreads=2EThreadPoolExecutor=2Er=
unWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor=2Ejava:1189)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomcat=2Eutil=2Ethreads=2EThreadPoolExecutor$Wor=
ker=2Erun(ThreadPoolExecutor=2Ejava:658)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Etomcat=2Eutil=2Ethreads=2ETaskThread$WrappingRun=
nable=2Erun(TaskThread=2Ejava:63)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Elang=2EThread=2Erun(Thread=2Ejava:1447)
>>>>>> Caused by: java=2Elang=2EIllegalArgumentException: can't parse argu=
ment number:
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Etext=2EMessageFormat=2EsetFormatFromPattern(=
MessageFormat=2Ejava:1644)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Etext=2EMessageFormat=2EapplyPatternImpl(Mess=
ageFormat=2Ejava:660)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Etext=2EMessageFormat=2E<init>(MessageFormat=
=2Ejava:516)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eutil=2EMemoizer$1=2Ecall(Memoizer=2Eja=
va:52)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Eutil=2Econcurrent=2EFutureTask=2Erun(FutureT=
ask=2Ejava:328)
>>>>>> 	at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eutil=2EMemoizer=2Ecompute(Memoizer=2Ej=
ava:59)
>>>>>> 	=2E=2E=2E 37 more
>>>>>> Caused by: java=2Elang=2ENumberFormatException: For input string: "=
"
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Elang=2ENumberFormatException=2EforInputStrin=
g(NumberFormatException=2Ejava:67)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Elang=2EInteger=2EparseInt(Integer=2Ejava:541=
)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Elang=2EInteger=2EparseInt(Integer=2Ejava:661=
)
>>>>>> 	at java=2Ebase/java=2Etext=2EMessageFormat=2EsetFormatFromPattern(=
MessageFormat=2Ejava:1642)
>>>>>> 	=2E=2E=2E 42 more
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Seems the server is not stopped or it takes too long to print all t=
hoses errors, I killed it after a few seconds an 1GB of log file ;-)
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> The project where the issue occured uses arquillian and "org=2Eapac=
he=2Etomee:arquillian-tomee-remote"=2E In the failed run, I still used 10=
=2E1=2E0 of this plugin, without trying to replace it with a snapshot versi=
on=2E Is it maybe caused by this one?
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Best regards
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Wolfgang
>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> Am 11=2E07=2E25 um 22:14 schrieb Wolfgang Knauf:
>>>>>>> Thanks, great work=2E
>>>>>>> I will give it a try the next few days and report back if there ar=
e further problems=2E
>>>>>>> Best regards
>>>>>>> Wolfgang
>>>>>>> Am 11=2E07=2E25 um 14:15 schrieb Richard Zowalla:
>>>>>>>> Hi Wolfgang,
>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>> we just pushed some changes, which should allow TomEE to run on J=
ava 24 (with some limitations regarding EJB method security, etc=2E)
>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>> Nightlies should be available via https://repository=2Eapache=2Eo=
rg/ content/groups/snapshots/org/apache/tomee/apache-tomee/10=2E1=2E1- SNAP=
SHOT/ soon=2E
>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>> Gru=C3=9F
>>>>>>>> Richard
>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>> On 2025/04/04 08:28:20 Wolfgang Knauf wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Hi all,
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> (sorry if this is a duplicate one, I already sent it a few days =
ago, but as it did not appear, I think it might be related to the fact that=
 I did not subscribe to the list)
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> TomEE 10=2E0=2E1 fails to launch with Java 24:
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> 01-Apr-2025 13:10:36=2E888 SCHWERWIEGEND [main] org=2Eapache=2Eo=
penejb=2Eutil=2EOpenEJBErrorHandler=2EhandleUnknownError FATAL ERROR: Unkno=
wn error in Assembler=2E Please send the following stack trace and this mes=
sage to users@tomee=2Eapache=2Eorg :
>>>>>>>>> org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EConstructionException: Error inv=
oking constructor: public org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2ETomcatSecurityS=
ervice()
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EReflectionUtil$Construct=
orFactory=2Ecreate(ReflectionUtil=2Ejava:981)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EObjectRecipe=2EinternalC=
reate(ObjectRecipe=2Ejava:279)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EAbstractRecipe=2Ecreate(=
AbstractRecipe=2Ejava:96)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EAbstractRecipe=2Ecreate(=
AbstractRecipe=2Ejava:61)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EAbstractRecipe=2Ecreate(=
AbstractRecipe=2Ejava:49)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eassembler=2Eclassic=2EAssembler=
=2EcreateSecurityService(Assembler=2Ejava:3553)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eassembler=2Eclassic=2EAssembler=
=2EbuildContainerSystem(Assembler=2Ejava:579)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Eassembler=2Eclassic=2EAssembler=
=2Ebuild(Assembler=2Ejava:497)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2EOpenEJB$Instance=2E<init>(OpenE=
JB=2Ejava:150)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2EOpenEJB=2Einit(OpenEJB=2Ejava:3=
07)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2ETomcatLoader=2Einitial=
ize(TomcatLoader=2Ejava:244)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2EServerListener=2Elifec=
ycleEvent(ServerListener=2Ejava:161)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Eutil=2ELifecycleBase=2EfireLif=
ecycleEvent(LifecycleBase=2Ejava:109)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Eutil=2ELifecycleBase=2EsetStat=
eInternal(LifecycleBase=2Ejava:389)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Eutil=2ELifecycleBase=2Einit(Li=
fecycleBase=2Ejava:123)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Estartup=2ECatalina=2Eload(Cata=
lina=2Ejava:712)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Estartup=2ECatalina=2Eload(Cata=
lina=2Ejava:735)
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/ jdk=2Einternal=2Ereflect=2EDirectMethodHand=
leAccessor=2Einvoke(DirectMethodHandleAccessor=2Ejava:104)
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/java=2Elang=2Ereflect=2EMethod=2Einvoke(Meth=
od=2Ejava:565)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Estartup=2EBootstrap=2Eload(Boo=
tstrap=2Ejava:302)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Ecatalina=2Estartup=2EBootstrap=2Emain(Boo=
tstrap=2Ejava:472)
>>>>>>>>> Caused by: java=2Elang=2EIllegalStateException: Could not instal=
l JACC Policy Provider: org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EJaccProv=
ider$Policy
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecur=
ityService=2EinstallPolicy(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:443)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecur=
ityService=2EinstallJacc(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:431)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecur=
ityService=2E<init>(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:94)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecur=
ityService=2E<init>(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:88)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Etomee=2Ecatalina=2ETomcatSecurityService=
=2E<init>(TomcatSecurityService=2Ejava:55)
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/ jdk=2Einternal=2Ereflect=2EDirectConstructo=
rHandleAccessor=2EnewInstance(DirectConstructorHandleAccessor=2Ejava:62)
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/ java=2Elang=2Ereflect=2EConstructor=2EnewIn=
stanceWithCaller(Constructor=2Ejava:499)
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/ java=2Elang=2Ereflect=2EConstructor=2EnewIn=
stance(Constructor=2Ejava:483)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Exbean=2Erecipe=2EReflectionUtil$Construct=
orFactory=2Ecreate(ReflectionUtil=2Ejava:971)
>>>>>>>>> =2E=2E=2E 20 more
>>>>>>>>> Caused by: java=2Elang=2EUnsupportedOperationException: Setting =
a system- wide Policy object is not supported
>>>>>>>>>      at java=2Ebase/java=2Esecurity=2EPolicy=2EsetPolicy(Policy=
=2Ejava:114)
>>>>>>>>>      at org=2Eapache=2Eopenejb=2Ecore=2Esecurity=2EAbstractSecur=
ityService=2EinstallPolicy(AbstractSecurityService=2Ejava:441)
>>>>>>>>> =2E=2E=2E 28 more
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> Is there something I should do about this (file a JIRA issue), o=
r is the Java 24 support already on your roadmap?
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> Best regards
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>>>>> Wolfgang
>>>>>>>>>=20
>>>>>> <log=2Etxt>
>>>>>=20
>>>>=20
>>>=20
>

------ANZHZVKZUCGMHAK1CN5LAME4TMXB8M--