Re: Hosting multiple domains

Hello Jeroen,
I am sorry it took me a while to respond.
I have to admit, I am still learning more and more about LDAP and the
inner things of Kolab.
Your email has helped, but I needed to learn more before I could
understand it better :)

I have worked now on allowing one Domain admin to manage several
domains. Through this I have learnt more about LDAP. I will post a
separate email on the mailing list about that later this morning.

> Code *should* use a search against cn=kolab,cn=config to retrieve the domain
> name space details, which *should* either;
>
>   - contain an inetdomainbasedn value, or
>
>   - lead to the attribute value used as the RDN, the "primary domain name
> space"^1, from which the "standard" root dn can therefore be derived^2.
I think I will experiment more over the adding of new domains, and try
to make them fully functional without needing to modify kolab.conf.
From what you have written, I will try to calculate the base_dn as you
described, and there is no need for using kolab.conf.

>> I am wondering that we still need the entries in kolab.conf for each
>> domain, eg. for the autocreate_folders and primary email address etc,
>> not just for the base_dn.
>
> Since these are domain name space specific settings, you would want them to
> exist.
>
> We could possibly work on making sure there is a section for global defaults
> as well.
A global defaults section would probably work for us, since the
domains of the customers should not be that different.

> The goal with Kolab 3 is to not require configuration files to be written out
> upon adding a domain name space (or upon editing, moving or deleting it, for
> that matter).
>
> I suppose this means adaptive code, for which of course I cannot be completely
> certain I've covered all use-cases. I think at the core, all of it is there.

[...]

> I suppose for (semi-)automated domain name space configuration like this is to
> really take of, we have to consider doing the following (alternative outlined
> below);
>
>   - Allow the specification of some sort of a domain_include_dir in [kolab] in
> kolab.conf(5). Let's say this will be /etc/kolab/domains.d/, or possibly
> /var/lib/kolab/domains.d/.
I am a little bit confused. I can understand your sentence above of
not wanting to write to config files when a domain is added. I think
it is good.
But your suggestion is still about working with config files, even if
it is a separate config file for each domain.
Or could that information which is currently in kolab.conf
(autocreate_folders, primary_mail) even be added to the information
about the domain in "cn=kolab,cn=config"?

Thank you also for explaining what kolabd does, that was helpful!

All the best,
  Timotheus