Question about KStars accessing (but not shipping) non-distributable data

Akarsh Simha <[email protected]> Thu, 25 Aug 2011 20:10:01 -0500
Newsgroups gmane.comp.kde.licensing
Message-ID <20110826011000.GA17463@ThinK9>
Hi

KStars wishes to use the following website to get updates on
supernovae:
http://www.cbat.eps.harvard.edu/lists/RecentSupernovae.html

The website says:

"This list may be freely pointed-to from your own Web site, but must
not be copied to your own site or otherwise redistributed."

However, KStars does not ship with any supernovae data by default. It
only downloads this list like any other HTTP client (using Python +
KIO), and then does some parsing to create a data file held in the
user's home directory.

This appears fair game to me, because well, it's just a HTTP client,
and you're downloading the data for personal use and running it
through some parsing.

But I'd like to verify if it's okay from the licensing gurus out here.

Thanks.

Regards
Akarsh
The KStars Team

PS: I'm copying this mail to the SoK student who wrote this feature,
    and I'd appreciate if you could "reply all", since he's not a
    member of this list.

_______________________________________________
Kde-licensing mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-licensing
signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, 836 B)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
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=K1+O
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----