Re: Very intermittent segmentation fault with boost::multiprecision

tjisana (泰志) via Boost-users <[email protected]>
Newsgroups gmane.comp.lib.boost.user
Message-ID <CAGXaPtD8qR8A2y3e8PZXzSi0gMnYi5GqHn0k3LPng7632rjSuw@mail.gmail.com> 
So, thanks to Marshall for clueing me in on address sanitizer.  Realized
that I failed to do bounds checking on a segment of code and solved the
read problem.  With that fixed I'm getting stack overflow due, it seems, to
the heavy recursion in my code (and using cpp_dec_).  I swapped out
cpp_dec_ for double and the problem has gone away.  Will figure out my
banker's rounding while I'm at it.  Here's the AddressSanitizer trace for
completeness (below) - maybe there's another issue afoot?

TJ

09:46:38.996500  | SPY   220211C00447000 | root: 0.000 | open: 0.000 |
high: 2.120 |  low: 0.000 | close: 1.680 |  bid: 1.680 |  ask: 1.690    |
1.414 |  0.009 |  0.306 |
09:47:03.456158  | SPY   220211C00447000 | order: MKT |  qty: 31.000 |
action: BUY | exchg: SMART
AddressSanitizer:DEADLYSIGNAL
=================================================================
==19612==ERROR: AddressSanitizer: stack-overflow on address 0x7f22fd7d5718
(pc 0x7f2300abe437 bp 0x7f22fd7d6360 sp 0x7f22fd7d5700 T0)
    #0 0x7f2300abe437  (/lib64/libasan.so.6+0xb9437)
    #1 0x7f2300a418fb in __interceptor_memcpy (/lib64/libasan.so.6+0x3c8fb)
    #2 0x7f2300927ba7 in std::basic_streambuf<char, std::char_traits<char>
>::xsputn(char const*, long) (/lib64/libstdc++.so.6+0x147ba7)
    #3 0x7f23009197d6 in std::ostream::write(char const*, long)
(/lib64/libstdc++.so.6+0x1397d6)
    #4 0x588c8a in EClientSocket::prepareBufferImpl(std::ostream&) const
../src/client/EClientSocket.cpp:217
    #5 0x588d7f in EClientSocket::prepareBuffer(std::ostream&) const
../src/client/EClientSocket.cpp:225
    #6 0x5548dc in EClient::reqCurrentTime() ../src/client/EClient.cpp:1234
    #7 0x4afda3 in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:409
    #8 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #9 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #10 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #11 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #12 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #13 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #14 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #15 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #16 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #17 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #18 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #19 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #20 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #21 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #22 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #23 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #24 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #25 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #26 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #27 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #28 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #29 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #30 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #31 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #32 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #33 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #34 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #35 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #36 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #37 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #38 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #39 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #40 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #41 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #42 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #43 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #44 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #45 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #46 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #47 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #48 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #49 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #50 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #51 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #52 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #53 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #54 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #55 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #56 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #57 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #58 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #59 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #60 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #61 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #62 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #63 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #64 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #65 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #66 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #67 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #68 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #69 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #70 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #71 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #72 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #73 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #74 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #75 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #76 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #77 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #78 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #79 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #80 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #81 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #82 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #83 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #84 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #85 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #86 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #87 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #88 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #89 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #90 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #91 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #92 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #93 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #94 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #95 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #96 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #97 0x4afdaf in ib_trading_engine::current_time()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:410
    #98 0x4b6dd5 in ib_trading_engine::tickPrice(long, TickType, double,
TickAttrib const&) ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:666
    #99 0x58b8f7 in EDecoder::processTickPriceMsg(char const*, char const*)
../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:65
    #100 0x5a50c7 in EDecoder::parseAndProcessMsg(char const*&, char
const*) ../src/client/EDecoder.cpp:2247
    #101 0x5d1f59 in EReader::processMsgs() ../src/client/EReader.cpp:282
    #102 0x4afd59 in ib_trading_engine::process_messages()
../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:405
    #103 0x4ad671 in operator() ../src/ib_trading_engine.cpp:261
    #104 0x4c1219 in operator()
/usr/include/boost/coroutine2/detail/push_control_block_cc.ipp:90
    #105 0x4c282d in __invoke_impl<boost::context::fiber,
boost::coroutines2::detail::push_coroutine<last_tick>::control_block::control_block<boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>
>(boost::context::preallocated,
boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>&&,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>&&)::<lambda(boost::context::fiber&&)>&,
boost::context::fiber> /usr/include/c++/11/bits/invoke.h:61
    #106 0x4c2618 in
__invoke<boost::coroutines2::detail::push_coroutine<last_tick>::control_block::control_block<boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>
>(boost::context::preallocated,
boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>&&,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>&&)::<lambda(boost::context::fiber&&)>&,
boost::context::fiber> /usr/include/c++/11/bits/invoke.h:97
    #107 0x4c257f in
invoke<boost::coroutines2::detail::push_coroutine<last_tick>::control_block::control_block<boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>
>(boost::context::preallocated,
boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>&&,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>&&)::<lambda(boost::context::fiber&&)>&,
boost::context::fiber> /usr/include/c++/11/functional:98
    #108 0x4c22df in run /usr/include/boost/context/fiber_fcontext.hpp:140
    #109 0x4c208b in
fiber_entry<boost::context::detail::fiber_record<boost::context::fiber,
boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>,
boost::coroutines2::detail::push_coroutine<last_tick>::control_block::control_block<boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>
>(boost::context::preallocated,
boost::context::basic_fixedsize_stack<boost::context::stack_traits>&&,
ib_trading_engine::run()::<lambda(boost::coroutines2::coroutine<last_tick>::pull_type&)>&&)::<lambda(boost::context::fiber&&)>
> > /usr/include/boost/context/fiber_fcontext.hpp:80
    #110 0x7f2300a0118e in make_fcontext
(/lib64/libboost_context.so.1.78.0+0x118e)

SUMMARY: AddressSanitizer: stack-overflow (/lib64/libasan.so.6+0xb9437)
==19612==ABORTING

On Fri, Feb 11, 2022 at 9:41 AM Phil Endecott via Boost-users <
[email protected]> wrote:

> Hi,
>
> tjisana wrote:
> > Trying to get to the root of a very intermittent seg fault in my program.
>
> This reminds me of the issue that I found while reviewing
> Boost.Multiprecision back in 2012:
>
> https://lists.boost.org/Archives/boost/2012/06/193862.php
>
> I did track that down and it was fixed, but in the process
> of investigating I got a poor impression of the implementation
> of the library and I felt that other similar issues were
> probably present. In my review, I said that I would not
> be confident using Boost.Multiprecision without verifying
> its answers against another implementation. Of course that's
> a decade ago and things may have changed - or not.
>
>
> Regards, Phil.
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Boost-users mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-users
>

_______________________________________________
Boost-users mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.boost.org/mailman/listinfo.cgi/boost-users
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.