Re: Inline SVG images and the need to prefix identifiers

On Tue, Oct 20, 2015 at 04:42:02PM +0200, Christian von Schultz wrote:
> Hello!
> 
> Background: SVG can be used inline in XHTML. My use case involves
> using MathML with SVG fallback using <annotation-xml>, to express
> mathematics in an XHTML document. I generate my SVG images using
> LaTeX, Poppler and Cairo.
> 
> The problem when inserting several SVG documents into the same XHTML
> document is that some id's are clashing.  The first SVG image has
>     <symbol overflow="visible" id="glyph0-0">
> and so has the second SVG image, and the third, and so on.
> Then the <use> element with xlink:href="#glyph0-0" doesn't know which
> symbol it refers to, and things aren't rendered properly. This problem
> arises with every id and every reference. Changing the identifiers and
> references when patching it all together is possible, but I worry a
> bit about missing something. There are several ways references can be
> made...
> 
> Would it make sense to have Cairo support inserting a prefix (or
> appending a suffix) to the element identifiers as they are generated?
> A "char *prefix" in the cairo_svg_document struct, for instance,
> enabling code such as
> _cairo_output_stream_printf (document->xml_node_glyphs,
> 	 "<symbol overflow=\"visible\" id=\"%sglyph%d-%d\">\n",
> 	 document->prefix,
> 	 font_id,
> 	 subset_glyph_index);
> in _cairo_svg_document_emit_glyph(), and similarly in the other
> emitters (alpha, image, pattern, clip, surface, linear, radial, mask)?
> 
> It would make life easier (and less error prone) for anyone trying to
> combine SVG files on the XML level.
> 
> Comments are welcome.

Sounds reasonable, I'd definitely entertain a patch to add this to cairo
if you'd like to submit one.

Bryce
-- 
cairo mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.cairographics.org/mailman/listinfo/cairo