Re: From: rewriting on [email protected]

Hi Corinna,

On Wed, 2025-07-16 at 12:53 +0200, Corinna Vinschen via Overseers
wrote:
> On Jul 11 10:06, Frank Ch. Eigler via Newlib wrote:
> > To please email services that are enforcing ever-tigher anti-spam
> > measures, we're turning on the mailman2 "dmarc_moderation_action"
> > option (back) to "Munge From".  It'll make some messages "uglier", but
> > should pass SPF+DMARC gauntlets.
> 
> Uhm... who asked for that?
> 
> We switched newlib to "not munging" a long time ago because we're
> handling patches and didn't want this munging.  Were there really
> any complaints in terms of the newlib ML?

We saw some bounces leading to unsubscribes because there were (was
one?) posters with a strict dmarc domain policy.

We can turn From rewriting off again if you feel that isn't happening
often enough to worry about.

Or as a "compromise" we could only turn on "Munge From" for p=reject
but not for p=quarantine or p=none.

Cheers,

Mark