Re: Mountain Lion Mail, reply from address

On Oct 25, 2012, at 7:32 PM, Chris Murphy wrote:

> Mountain Lion Mail appears to have reply to mail from address =
completely broken, but I'm hoping maybe this is just user error.
>=20
> There are three accounts a@, b@, c@. Mail arrives into each of the =
three accounts. When I click on email in any of the three accounts and =
reply, by default the =46rom account is the same account received. There =
is a preference for this.
>=20
> It used to be the case, those emails, if placed into Mailboxes =
(folders) per Rules, that you'd get the same behavior. If I click on an =
email in "Omni Admin" folder, and reply, the =46rom email account is set =
to the account that received the mail.
>=20
> That is no longer what I'm experiencing. In all mail folders, replying =
causes the =46rom setting to always be from account a@. The first =
account. I see no setting to change this behavior. So what's been =
happening to me since the "upgrade" to Mountain Lion, I'm replying to =
listserve emails and the mails are bouncing because of course they are =
sent from the wrong email account.

Is this local mailboxes (pop?) or server mailboxes with imap that the =
rules are moving the files into folders for?  I've long seen an issue =
where a mail comes in to  [email protected] but a rule moves it into a folder that =
resides in [email protected] address.  This is with IMAP and folders on the =
server.  When I reply, the from is set to the account for the mailbox =
the mail ended up in by rules and not the one that received it.  This =
has long been the case (been happening to me on 10.6 and 10.7 at least =
since forever).  Is this what you are doing or is it different?