Re: Updating defsystem dependencies

On 4/15/26 7:20 AM, Barton Willis wrote:

> Might straightening out these dependences eliminate some compiler 
> warnings such as:
>
> ; compilation finished in 0:00:00.620
> STYLE-WARNING:
>    2 calls to MAXIMA::$LIMIT were compiled before a compiler-macro was 
> defined
>    for it. A declaration of NOTINLINE at the call sites will eliminate 
> this
>    warning, as will defining the compiler-macro before its first 
> potential use.
> ;
> ; compilation unit finished
> ;   printed 1 note
>
> The dozens and dozens of warnings distract from messages that are 
> important.

I don’t know yet, but if it doesn’t, that’s next on the list.

There’s also the issue with gcl that prints tons of warnings about 
function signatures changing or something. I have not checked to see if 
they’re due to compilation order or not.

>
> --Barton
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
> *From:* Raymond Toy <[email protected]>
> *Sent:* Saturday, April 11, 2026 12:22 AM
> *To:* <[email protected]> 
> <[email protected]>
> *Subject:* [Maxima-discuss] Updating defsystem dependencies
>
> 	
> Caution: Non-NU Email
>
>
> Well, I asked Claude to check the dependencies of all the lisp files.  
> Here is what it said.  I'll look into soon and fix this up if needed.  
> I think moving some macros and functions around would be helpful too 
> instead of just leaving this as they are.
>
> I'll update the asdf file too.
>
>
>     Bugs fixed
>
>
>       1 — Duplicate |:depends-on| in |command-line|
>
> MK:DEFSYSTEM silently discards all but the last |:depends-on| clause 
> per module. |command-line| had two, so its |defmfun| dependency was 
> being dropped. Fixed by merging into one: |:depends-on ("defmfun" 
> "getopt")|.
>
>
>       2 — |pois3| (key / bp / order / …) loaded far too late
>
> |pois3| was in |poisson-series| (nearly last) but its macros are 
> called at compile time by *cl-info, init-cl, inmis, intl, mdebug, 
> mutils, nparse, plot, rand-mt19937, bessel, expintegral, defint, hyp, 
> hypgeo, and limit* — all compiled far earlier. Promoted to a new early 
> |poisson-macros| module, placed immediately after |globals|.
>
>
>       3 — |pade| (num / denom / red) loaded far too late
>
> |pade| was in |miscellaneous| (very late) but its three macros are 
> used across *simp, float, sin, limit, hayat, rat3b, rat3e, combin, 
> displa, nrat4, nisimp, irinte, nforma, rpart, series, sinint, mactex, 
> trigo, and risch*. Promoted to a new early |pade-macros| module.
>
>
>       4 — |spgcd| (len / matrix) loaded too late
>
> |spgcd| was in |gcd| (late) but |len| and |matrix| are used by *float, 
> getopt, linnew, numth, plot, trigo, init-cl, and intl*. Promoted to a 
> new early |spgcd-macros| module before |simplification|.
>
>
>       5 — |evaluator| (mlisp → |msetq|) must precede |commands| and
>       |simplification|
>
> |msetq| is a compile-time macro needed by |comm|, |csimp2|, |inmis|, 
> |matcom|, |matrun|, |nparse|, |optim|, |suprv1|, |trans2|, |trans4|, 
> |transl|, and |trmode|. The |evaluator| module is now placed before 
> |commands| and |simplification|, and those modules gain |:depends-on 
> ("evaluator")|.
>
>
>       6 — |transm| (tr / maref / maset / def%tr) must precede
>       |factoring| and |simplification|
>
> |transm| was in |maxima-language-compiler-macros| which was ordered 
> after |factoring| and |simplification|. But |algfac|, |nalgfa| 
> (factoring), |float| (simplification), |linnew|, |newdet|, and 
> |trgred| all use its macros. The module is now placed at position 15 — 
> before |factoring| and |simplification| — and those modules gain the 
> dependency.
>
>
>       7 — |risch| (pair) must precede |utility-macros|, |utilities|,
>       |trigonometry|, and |miscellaneous|
>
> |risch| was in |integration| but |pair| is called by |mforma| 
> (utility-macros), |mutils| (utilities), |series| (miscellaneous), and 
> |trgred| (trigonometry). |integration| is now placed before 
> |trigonometry| and |miscellaneous|, both of which gain |:depends-on 
> ("integration")|.
>
>
>       8 — |display| did not depend on |reader|
>
> |displa.lisp| uses |def-rbp| from |nparse| (reader module). Added 
> |:depends-on ("reader")| to |display|.
>
>
>       9 — |miscellaneous| did not depend on |reader| or |integration|
>
> |gamma| and |nset| use |nparse| macros; |series| uses |risch→pair| and 
> |schatc→alist-bind|. Added both |reader| and |integration| as 
> dependencies.
>
>
>       10 — |schatc| (pattern-matching) macros needed by limits,
>       trigonometry, integration
>
> |preserve|, |alist-bind|, and |schatchen-cond| are called by |limit|, 
> |trgred|, and |sin| respectively. |limits|, |trigonometry|, and 
> |integration| now depend on |pattern-matching|.
>
>
&#8203;

_______________________________________________
Maxima-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/maxima-discuss