RE: SAR Patch for Kannel

Hi list,
I have updated the patch to be applicable to current version of gw
Also reaction on nack is now implemented. (ESAR - not yet)
Attached patch is the next version of SAR-cumulative

I never saw problems described by Dave, and our mms server is working fine
with patched gw,
but really I have tested only T68i, 7650, 7210. Also I've tested 6310i to
download applications through
this gw without any problem.

Dave, 
It's very interesting to see tcpdump of failed sessions
(didnot you forget to use only session oriented mode?)

Igor


> -----Original Message-----
> From: Dave White [mailto:[email protected]]
> Sent: Wednesday, November 06, 2002 4:11 PM
> To: [email protected]
> Cc: [email protected]
> Subject: Re: SAR Patch for Kannel
> 
> 
> [email protected] wrote:
> > Hello Dave,
> > 
> > You once "promissed" :) to send your updated SAR patch to 
> the Kannel 
> > mailing list. I tried to find this email on the list but 
> couldn't find it.
> > 
> > Could you send your latest version to the list? Possible with 
> > your findings like quality, missing features, working phones. 
> > Alternatively I can offer you some hosting space on my ADSL box if 
> > nescessary. This would allow a simple web-page with 
> detailed info on the 
> > patch.
> > 
> > Best regards,
> > 
> > Ruud Schramp
> > 
> > 
> 
> I adapted this patch from the two SAR patches posted to the list; the 
> changes I made to the work of Igor and Vjacheslav were only simple 
> changes needed to apply the path to the latest Kannel CVS snapshot.
> 
> "It worked for me" -- sort of. Since I didn't have time to go 
> after the 
> problems, I haven't sent it out or tried to identify the 
> concrete problems.
> 
> In particular, SAR on responses seems to work about 50% of 
> the time with 
> a Nokia 7650 (tested by downloading J2ME apps) and SAR on 
> requests seems 
> not to work at all with Nokia devices (tested with attempted 
> MMS-Post).
> 
> Furthermore, I suspect that CVS has changed enough that this 
> new patch 
> won't apply.
> 
> Here it is; I suspect that members of the core team are quite a bit 
> further along, and I'd recommend waiting for their output. I 
> would not 
> recommend this patch for a production system; I have seen numerous 
> wapbox hangs (not crashes, hangs) using this.
> 
> David WHITE
> CONNECT AUSTRIA
> 
>