Re: ppg push - product-name attr.

Hi Aarno,

On Thursday, March 20, 2003, at 09:54 AM, Aarno Syvänen wrote:

> this is a bug in any case: Kannel should ignore attributes it does 
> understand, expect in the case of fatal errors (phone number,
> for instance). What specs are referring ? Kannel may even implement 
> product-name ;)

First the WAP 2.0 specs, document WAP-247-PAP-20010429-a.pdf 
(http://www1.wapforum.org/tech/terms.asp?doc=WAP-247-PAP-20010429-a.pdf), 
section 8.1:

> <!ELEMENT pap ( push-message
> | push-response
> | cancel-message
> | cancel-response
> | resultnotification-message
> | resultnotification-response
> | statusquery-message
> | statusquery-response
> | ccq-message
> | ccq-response
> | badmessage-response) >
>
> <!ATTLIST pap
> product-name CDATA #IMPLIED
> >
>
> The pap element specifies a set of elements that describe messages. The 
> elements are tagged with "message" or
> "response" suffix to make it clear when they are messages or responses 
> to messages.
>
> Attributes
>
> product-name=CDATA
>
> This attribute contains the name or identification of the pap handling 
> application that generated the message. It
> may be useful in operational compatibility between various vendor 
> implementations.

I also checked the 1.2.1 specs, document WAP-164-PAP-19991108-a.pdf 
(http://www1.wapforum.org/tech/terms.asp?doc=WAP-164-PAP-19991108-a.pdf), 
section 9.1, which is exactly the same.

,To conclude, Kannel should handle this ok ;) It might of course set the 
attribute in pap result documents as well.

Regards,

Bas.