Re: MZ and Google

"Glenn (formerly [email protected])" <[email protected]> Thu, 04 Jun 2009 01:30:36 -0700
Newsgroups gmane.comp.mozilla.multizilla
Organization The Mozdev Foundation - news server
Message-ID <[email protected]>
On approximately 6/2/2009 10:12 PM, came the following characters from 
the keyboard of Glenn (formerly [email protected]):
> On approximately 6/1/2009 1:09 PM, came the following characters from 
> the keyboard of Andrea:
>> I'm using SeaMonkey with MZ 1.8.3.4e, and when I open up a new tab and 
>> go to Google, it reverts back to another tab with a different Google 
>> search and replaces that search. This only happens if I click on the 
>> Google bookmark saved on my personal toolbar. If I type in the 
>> Google.com URL, I can have multiple searches open. I deleted that 
>> bookmark and saved a fresh one, but it didn't help. I used to be able 
>> to have several Google searches open without typing the URL in. I 
>> don't have this problem when I use SeaMonkey without MZ. (I know this 
>> because I disabled MZ with the extension manager without thinking 
>> ahead and realizing that I couldn't easily add it back! And I did this 
>> once before too but obviously didn't learn from experience. However, 
>> the information about how to bring MZ back is online, so it's working 
>> now.) Thanks. 
> 
> 
> I've noticed the same effect, but haven't (yet) attempted to track it down.


After reading the additional postings here, I had an inspiration, and 
was able to cure my symptom.

In the Tabs section of Multizilla preferences, there is a Tab Behavior 
tab, at the bottom is "duplicated link protection" which I had turned on 
at some point, as it sounds like a good idea. Turning it off cures this 
symptom, and turning it back on causes it to recur.

Why did the symptom show up when it did? Not sure if I just didn't 
notice the effect immediately, or if the check for "duplicated link" for 
a tab is erroneous in some manner, or if it is affected somehow by a 
change that Google has made. But after a search, the tab should have a 
URL that is different than the URL for a new search... and different 
than the URL for other search results. Yet somehow, when this setting is 
turned on, if a tab has existing Google search results, then clicking 
the bookmark for a new Google search takes one to the tab containing the 
Google search results.

When I first noticed this, it was very irritating to me, and I think I 
would have noticed it soon after it occurred, because I use Google 
search heavily, and often have multiple search tabs open. It is for this 
reason, that I think it is somehow affected by some change that Google 
has made, but I don't know what change, and I haven't examined the 
MultiZilla code to discover how it decides a tab is duplicated (since, 
in this case, it seems that the URLs are different). I don't really 
think that it happened at a time when I upgraded versions of SeaMonkey 
or MultiZilla, as I have upgraded neither for quite some time (on this 
particular machine), yet the symptom seemed to show up just in the last 
few months.

SeaMonkey is 1.1.6 and MZ is 1.8.3.4e, here.

So I still haven't tracked down the source of the change in behavior, 
but this is a work-around of sorts... is that setting possible to 
customize on a site-by-site manner?  I didn't look to see...


-- 
Glenn -- http://nevcal.com/glenn/contact_me.html
================================================
Reply in this newsgroup, or contact me privately via above link.
I am not concealing my identity, as this is my real web site.
I am not impersonating [email protected] -- that address is not for a person.