Re: Splitting Ogg Vorbis file

2009/6/28 [email protected] <[email protected]>:
>> So my questions are: what does "overlap-add nature of vorbis" means?
>
> Decoding a Vorbis packet makes use of the two previous packets
> (that's also known as 'preroll'). Thus, if you're missing those packets,
> you'll get different data out (though I don't know *how* different
> that output would be).

My understanding is that for Vorbis, no data will be produced until
the third packet is received, so if you're missing the 2 previous
preroll packets then the output PCM stream will simply be shorter, ie.
missing the first 2 packets worth of audio (a few hundredths of a
second).

For speex, I understand that data will be produced from the first
packets, but if the decoder is first fed a few earlier packets then
the PCM data output after the desired split point will be closer to
the original data. Jean-Marc once recommended 3 packets of preroll for
Speex.

> You'd need this even if you want to cut at a packet granularity.

Right, ie. the preroll packets should appear in both files.

Conrad.