[Fwd: Game Reviews]

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.
--------------080309090005060503090808
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit



-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Game Reviews
Date: Sat, 08 Jun 2002 18:59:07 +1000
From: Nigel Stewart <[email protected]>
To: opencd-devel <[email protected]>



Hello,

Here are a couple of reviews, taken at random from the
list.  Feel free to argue here, if these are your favorites! :-)

Regards,

Nigel Stewart





--------------080309090005060503090808
Content-Type: text/plain;
 name="mantis.txt"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline;
 filename="mantis.txt"

Review form (Beta edition)

<Section 1: Project information>

Reviewed by Nigel Stewart ([email protected])

--------------------------------------
Program name:  MantisChess
--------------------------------------
Version:       1.04
--------------------------------------
Last Release Date: 10th Feb 2002
--------------------------------------
Website:       http://thecct.51.net/
--------------------------------------
Binary URL:    http://thecct.51.net/download.php?id=2
--------------------------------------
Binary Size:   84Kb
--------------------------------------
Source URL:    As above, binary and source in same ZIP
--------------------------------------
Source Size: 
--------------------------------------
Licence:       GPL
--------------------------------------
Languages:     en, zh
--------------------------------------
Platforms supported:  Windows 
--------------------------------------
Competitors: 
--------------------------------------
User Market: Home
--------------------------------------
Installer:   No
--------------------------------------
Uninstaller: No
--------------------------------------

<Section 2: Descriptive review>

--------------------------------------
Description: 

This is a Chinese version of chess with
different rules to western chess.
(The board is nine squares wide)  
Gameplay style is human against 
computer player.

--------------------------------------
Comments Overall: 

Interesting, but lacking explanation of
the rules, even a web link would be a
big help to non-Chinese person.  

--------------------------------------
Comments on Installation/Uninstallation: 

The ZIP distribution includes a binary
and source.  There is no install/uninstall
feature at all.

--------------------------------------
Notable features(or lack of)/bugs: 

Lacking documentation and explanation.
No noticable bugs.
On a 1024x768 desktop, a bit squinty to
look at, no resize feature.

--------------------------------------
Learning Curve: 

Very steep for uninitiated.

--------------------------------------
Prerequisites: 

None

--------------------------------------
Screenshot URLs: 

http://thecct.51.net/image/cchess_preview_s.jpg

--------------------------------------

<Section 3: Numerical review>

--------------------------------------
Documentation:     2
--------------------------------------
Ease-of-use:       2
--------------------------------------
Appearance:        8
--------------------------------------
Stability:         9
--------------------------------------
Kill-Factor:       4
-------------------------------------- 


--------------080309090005060503090808
Content-Type: text/plain;
 name="minesperf.txt"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline;
 filename="minesperf.txt"

Review form (Beta edition)

<Section 1: Project information>

Reviewed by Nigel Stewart ([email protected])

--------------------------------------
Program name:    Mines-Perfect
--------------------------------------
Version:         1.2a
--------------------------------------
Last Release Date:  16th Jan 2001
--------------------------------------
Website:  http://www.czeppi.de/english/index.html
--------------------------------------
Binary URL:   http://prdownloads.sourceforge.net/mines-perfect/mines121.zip?download
--------------------------------------
Binary Size:  406699
--------------------------------------
Source URL:   http://prdownloads.sourceforge.net/mines-perfect/mines121_src.zip?download
--------------------------------------
Source Size:  76282
--------------------------------------
Licence:      GPL
--------------------------------------
Languages:    en, de
--------------------------------------
Platforms supported: Windows
--------------------------------------
Competitors:  Microsoft MineSweeper
--------------------------------------
User Market:  Home
--------------------------------------
Installer:    NO
--------------------------------------
Uninstaller:  NO
--------------------------------------

<Section 2: Descriptive review>

--------------------------------------
Description: 

An enhanced version of the Microsoft
Minesweeper game with several variations
in play.  Square, triangle or hexagon grid.
Hint and solve features.  Customisation
of difficulty level.

--------------------------------------
Comments Overall: 

Main problem is that help file and some
application dialogs are in German.  It looks
like a while since the website and program
were updated, a little bit of maintenance
and translation work is needed.

--------------------------------------
Comments on Installation/Uninstallation: 

No Installer. 

--------------------------------------
Notable features(or lack of)/bugs: 

Very esy to use.
Mix of English and German can be jarring.
Needs an installer.

--------------------------------------
Learning Curve: 

Low

--------------------------------------
Prerequisites: 

None

--------------------------------------
Screenshot URLs: 

http://www.czeppi.de/squares.gif

--------------------------------------

<Section 3: Numerical review>

--------------------------------------
Documentation:  5 (German Only)
--------------------------------------
Ease-of-use:    8
--------------------------------------
Appearance:     8
--------------------------------------
Stability:      8
--------------------------------------
Kill-Factor:    3
-------------------------------------- 


--------------080309090005060503090808--


_______________________________________________________________

Don't miss the 2002 Sprint PCS Application Developer's Conference
August 25-28 in Las Vegas - http://devcon.sprintpcs.com/adp/index.cfm?source=osdntextlink