Re: ImportError: No module named 'PyQt5.sip'

On 29/04/2020 00:54, Patrick Stinson wrote:
> Thanks for the explanation.
> 
> So an extension like PyQt5, during it’s own configure phase, should
> generate it’s own private sip module using the installed sip-module
> tool from sip 5? Then that private sip module is built during PyQt5’s
> build phase, and installed in the PyQt5 package dir during the PyQt5
> install phase?

No. You only need to build PyQt5.sip when the implementation of the sip 
module changes. That happens a lot less often than changes to PyQt5.

In my internal build environment PyQt5.sip and PyQt5 itself are 
completely separate packages.

Phil

>> On Apr 28, 2020, at 1:08 PM, Phil Thompson 
>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>> 
>> With SIP v4 the code generator and the sip module were tied together. 
>> Before private sip modules were introduced "building SIP" meant 
>> building them both. This approach causes many problems...
>> 
>> - otherwise unrelated packages have a dependency on a common sip 
>> module and may have conflicting version requirements. Private sip 
>> modules (pioneered by Robin Dunn for wxPython) avoid this problem.
>> 
>> - the code generator and the sip module have the same version number. 
>> It can make it impossible to upgrade the code generator (for bug 
>> fixes) without having to upgrade the sip module. It also makes 
>> semantic versioning impossible.
>> 
>> The SIP v5 code generator (ie. SIP) has its own (semantic) version 
>> number.  The sip module has its own, completely independent, 
>> (semantic) version number. The sip module is created using SIP v5's 
>> sip-module tool. sip-module will build *any* supported version of the 
>> sip module (see the --abi-version option). This means you can update 
>> SIP v5 to a later version but still use an older version of the sip 
>> module.
>> 
>> Phil
>> 
>> On 28/04/2020 21:41, Patrick Stinson wrote:
>>> I have gone through them. The closest thing I found that applies 
>>> might be:
>>> https://www.riverbankcomputing.com/static/Docs/sip/introduction.html#support-for-old-versions-of-python
>>> <https://www.riverbankcomputing.com/static/Docs/sip/introduction.html#support-for-old-versions-of-python>
>>> But I’m not sure. It may just be me, but I find it hard to follow and
>>> decided it didn’t have anything to do with my question.
>>> Or am I off base? I am fairly familiar with sip 4, but having trouble
>>> understanding the roadmap to move to sip-5. Maybe I have to have a
>>> better understanding of wheels?
>>>> On Apr 28, 2020, at 12:33 PM, Phil Thompson 
>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>> On 28/04/2020 19:03, Patrick Stinson wrote:
>>>>> Also, I just tried:
>>>>> 	pip install .
>>>>> For sip-5.2.0 with Python-3.7.7 and it didn’t install the sip 
>>>>> module
>>>>> in site-packages or site-packages/PyQt5.
>>>>> Not sure what to do there….
>>>> Read the docs? Installing SIP v5 has nothing to do with installing 
>>>> the sip module.
>>>> Phil
>>>>>> On Apr 28, 2020, at 5:51 AM, Patrick Stinson 
>>>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>>> I suppose this is more of a pip question at this point, but do you 
>>>>>> know how to get:
>>>>>> pip install .
>>>>>> or
>>>>>> pip install PyQt5_sip-12.7.2.tar.gz
>>>>>> to build with debugging symbols? At first glance I don’t see 
>>>>>> anything like that in the pip docs.
>>>>>>> On Apr 28, 2020, at 5:48 AM, Patrick Stinson 
>>>>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>>>> Oh wow, it looks like I am also out of touch with pip and its 
>>>>>>> capabilities.
>>>>>>> “pip install .” Worked for me using sip-5.2.0.tar.gz.
>>>>>>> Sounds like your idea to detect setup.py is a good one, however.
>>>>>>>> On Apr 28, 2020, at 5:09 AM, Phil Thompson 
>>>>>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>>>>> Aah - I never build in that particular way, I always use pip to 
>>>>>>>> build the PyQt5.sip module.
>>>>>>>> To build from an unpacked source package...
>>>>>>>> pip install .
>>>>>>>> To build from a local source package...
>>>>>>>> pip install PyQt5_sip-12.7.2.tar.gz
>>>>>>>> To build from source from PyPI...
>>>>>>>> pip install --no-binary :all: PyQt5-sip
>>>>>>>> I'll try and detect if 'python setup.py' is being used and 
>>>>>>>> either fix it or fail with an error message.
>>>>>>>> Phil
>>>>>>>> On 28/04/2020 13:39, Patrick Stinson wrote:
>>>>>>>>> Phil,
>>>>>>>>> It seems to me that this is likely documented somewhere since 
>>>>>>>>> it is a
>>>>>>>>> latest-version source build with generic options?
>>>>>>>>> -Patrick
>>>>>>>>>> On Apr 27, 2020, at 11:26 PM, Patrick Stinson 
>>>>>>>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>> Now I am asking the same question as the OP. I built 
>>>>>>>>>> Python-3.8.4, sip-5.2.0, and PyQt5-5.14.2 on macOS and got the 
>>>>>>>>>> same error.
>>>>>>>>>> I built sip with “python setup.py install”
>>>>>>>>>> turin:vendor patrick$ python -c "import PyQt5.QtGui"
>>>>>>>>>> Traceback (most recent call last):
>>>>>>>>>> File "<string>", line 1, in <module>
>>>>>>>>>> ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'PyQt5.sip'
>>>>>>>>>> -Patrick
>>>>>>>>>>> On Apr 27, 2020, at 1:33 PM, Phil Thompson 
>>>>>>>>>>> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>>> On 27/04/2020 22:19, Gabriele Bulfon wrote:
>>>>>>>>>>>> Great Phil, that's where I pulled sources for both of them.
>>>>>>>>>>>> I have built and packaged PyQt5-sip and PyQt5 from those 
>>>>>>>>>>>> sources,
>>>>>>>>>>>> after building and packaging sip5 and PyQt-builder.
>>>>>>>>>>>> Maybe there's something wrong in what I'm delivering to the 
>>>>>>>>>>>> system
>>>>>>>>>>>> with PyQt5-sip?
>>>>>>>>>>>> Here's a brief of the files delivered by my package, as in 
>>>>>>>>>>>> the package
>>>>>>>>>>>> definition file (pkg, solaris).
>>>>>>>>>>>> I derived this from the prototype area generated by the 
>>>>>>>>>>>> build/install
>>>>>>>>>>>> on the prototype install root.
>>>>>>>>>>>> I bet something is wrong with the sip.cpython-35m.so 
>>>>>>>>>>>> file...I still
>>>>>>>>>>>> don't understand how these cpython so files are looked up, 
>>>>>>>>>>>> but that is
>>>>>>>>>>>> what the build system created in the prototype area.
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir path=usr
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir path=usr/lib
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5
>>>>>>>>>>>> dir
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5_sip-12.7.2-py$(PYVER).egg-info
>>>>>>>>>>>> file 
>>>>>>>>>>>> usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5/sip.cpython-35m.so
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5/sip.cpython-35m.so
>>>>>>>>>>>> file
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5_sip-12.7.2-py$(PYVER).egg-info/PKG-INFO
>>>>>>>>>>>> file
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5_sip-12.7.2-py$(PYVER).egg-info/SOURCES.txt
>>>>>>>>>>>> file
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5_sip-12.7.2-py$(PYVER).egg-info/dependency_links.txt
>>>>>>>>>>>> file
>>>>>>>>>>>> path=usr/lib/python$(PYVER)/vendor-packages/PyQt5_sip-12.7.2-py$(PYVER).egg-info/top_level.txt
>>>>>>>>>>> I would expect to see .dist-info rather than .egg-info. Maybe 
>>>>>>>>>>> your setuptools is too old.
>>>>>>>>>>> Phil
>>