Re: removed files reappearing when they shouldn't

Larry Jones wrote:
> Robert Hayes writes:
> 
>>Basically, consider what happens if you:
>> - add a file "foo" to directory "bar" at, say, 11:00
>> - check it out to two locations, "a" and "b" at 11:01
>> - do a cvs remove of foo from location "a" at 11:02
> 
> 
> Do you commit the remove?  I assume so, otherwise you wouldn't get the
> up-to-date check failure.
> 

Yes, I did.

> 
>> - modify foo in location "b", "Up-to-date check failed" error, update
>>(fine) and then commit changes at 11:03
> 
> 
> The update shouldn't be fine, you should get a conflict saying that foo
> is modified but no longer in the repository.
> 

That's right - by fine, I meant that it was fine to get that error since 
I expected a conflict, not that the update was fine :)

> 
>>Clear?  (btw, I'm using cvs version 1.11)
> 
> 
> 1.11 is pretty old, I suggest you upgrade to the current release
> (1.11.5, which you can get from www.cvshome.org).
> 

Ok, I will try this.

> 
>>Now, this is where things happen that I don't understand.
>> - if I check out "bar" at 11:06 (not specifying any
>>revision/tag/branch/time details), the file "foo" is not there.
>> - if I check out "bar" at 11:06 (specifying a time such as "2 seconds
>>ago"), the file "foo" is still not there.
>> - however, if I check out "bar" at 11:06 (setting the time to be,
>>e.g. what the time was a short time ago (say 11:05)), the file "foo"
>>_is_ there.
>>Is that not bizarre?
> 
> 
> If you do a log on the file, all should be clear.  When you checked in
> the changes from b, you effectively resurrected the dead file but CVS
> didn't notice and left it in the Attic rather than moving it back into
> the main directory.  On a normal checkout with no tag or date, CVS
> doesn't look in the Attic, so you don't get the file even though it's
> alive.  When you use an explicit date/time that's during the time the
> file was dead, CVS looks in the Attic but you don't get the file because
> it's dead.  When you use an explicit date/time that's during the time
> the file is alive, you get that revision.

That is correct.  However, I used an explicit date/time that was during 
the time the file was dead (i.e. I removed file "foo" at time "11:02", 
tried to check it out (specifying the time as 11:05) and it was there, 
when clearly it shouldn't have been!).

I'm going to assume that it's a bug in the version of the server I have 
and see if it goes when I upgrade.

thanks for the answer, apologies for my delay in replying!

~Robert Hayes

---------------------------------

www.havok.com
Realtime Interactive Physics

---------------------------------