update bug (was: adding on branch)

[email protected] (Pierre Asselin)
Newsgroups gmane.comp.version-control.cvs.bugs
Organization http://extra.newsguy.com
Message-ID <[email protected]>
I changed the title to attract new readers.  Paul, your problem has
nothing to do with the Attic or dead trunk revisions.  It also happens
if a file added on the trunk and a file with the same name is
imported later.  To reproduce,

    import a test tree
    check out the trunk
    add a file "gatcha" on the trunk, commit, delete the sandbox
    add a file "gatcha" to the initial import tree, do a second import
    cvs checkout -j first_import -j second_import

You get a warning about "gatcha", but once the warning flies off the
screen there is no indication of a conflict.  The merge logic seems to be:

    1) file has the new import tag but not the old, so must add
    2) file is already present, can't add;  warn
    3) oh, well.

I would much prefer if update (or checkout -j -j), finding the file
already in the sandbox, attempted the three-way merge between sandbox
and import, with /dev/null as the common ancestor.  That seems to often
yield a file with the two versions bracketed by conflict markers, even
if the two versions are almost identical.  Not very good, but at least
it's fail-safe.  Currently, the conflict information is lost.

Yow.  I guess I'll have to do my merges like I do my imports and
capture the screen output

    cvs update -j blah -j blahblah 2> ../err | tee ../out
lmpx.com only provides a reader for public news (NNTP) servers. It is not affiliated with the servers or forums shown here and is not responsible for the content of articles, which is written by their respective authors.