Re: Re: Find bookmarks comments

El dom, 31-08-2003 a las 11:27, Crispin Flowerday escribió:
> Ric,
> 
> On Sun, 2003-08-31 at 02:31, Ricardo Fernández Pascual wrote:
> > El sáb, 30-08-2003 a las 13:11, Tommi Komulainen escribió:
> > 
> > > Looks better and better after every iteration :)  Here's a few more:
> 
> Indeed, it is looking really good now, I just have a few comments:
> 
> 
> 1) You shouldn't be able to expand the folders in the right hand pane,
> it looks very confusing when you do have the folder trees expanded in
> both panes

I don't agree. The folders are not expanded by default, so it is not
confusing. Unless the user wants to expand the folder it will not be
expanded. And not expandable folders are quite useless really.

> 
> 2) double click on a folder in the right pane should navigate into that
> folder (rather than opening the properties window), ditto double click
> on the folder in the left pane should open it, think of a file manager.

About double click on the right pane: I think double clicking on folder
should do the same thing as double clicking on sites. Either open the
properties window or activate it.

About double click on the left pane: Single clicking on a folder already
opens it in the right pane, or do you mean something different?

> 3) double click on a bookmark should open the bookmark in the current
> tab (rather than open the properties dialog).

This could be done, but I don't think it would be a good idea:

When the editor is docked, this is already the current behaviour. In
that case it is obvious which is the current tab (because it is just
there, in the same window). 

When the editor is not docked there is not any obvious current tab. The
galeon window that opened the bookmark editor can be on another
workspace, can be minimized or can be closed. It would be confusing if
double clicking something would start loading a page in a different
window which can be totally unrelated to the current window.

Also, my main assumption about the independent editor and the sidebar is
that you use the editor to manage your bookmarks and edit them, and you
use the sidebar for browsing your bookmark collection.


> 4) also according the to the HIG the first item in the context menu
> should be the double click action, so 'open' should be added to the top
> of the context menu.

I would prefer not making the bookmarks context menu bigger, but this
can be addressed if necessary.

> 5) Accelerators are missing for the radio buttons.
> 

I hate accelerators! ;)

> 6) The creating a new boomark/folder/alias seems to crash the editor.

I reproduced it just now. It's an easy fix.

> Sorry for the long list, I do however like it a lot.
> 

Hey, not problem. That's the point of UI review.

> Cheers
> 
> Crispin

-- 
Ricardo Fernández Pascual
[email protected]
Murcia. España.




-------------------------------------------------------
This sf.net email is sponsored by:ThinkGeek
Welcome to geek heaven.
http://thinkgeek.com/sf