RE: Questions prompted by the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

------=_NextPart_000_0031_01C2EC82.46888190
Content-Type: text/plain;
	charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

I think that companies working on WS-ReliableMessaging bodes well for the
widespread adoption of an sigle, open, RF, interoperable reliability
specification that architects well with other Web service specifications.  
 
What I'm really surprised by is the pushback that people are giving on the
possibility that ws-rm won't automatically go to the oasis ws-reliability
TC.   One of the biggest differences between the W3C and OASIS is that the
W3C has a community review process for new working groups.  The goal at the
W3C being to have a charter for a working group that all the W3C Members can
live with and is technically consistent with other works in progress.
Indeed, the work that the W3C Team and member companies do to come up with
such a charter and then the 4 week AC review period are the biggest
contributors to the length of time to form a Working Group, IMO.  OASIS has
no such intent or process.   
 
If you like forming WG's quickly, you can't ALSO want there to be consensus
in the industry around a single Working Group and it's charter.  Time to
market or consensus, pick one.  
 
Continuing the community review of charters a little further, TC's can
arbitrarily change their charter without a community review.  The IP issues
around changes in charters alone gives me the willies, like how the heck do
you do early IP disclosure if the charter can change???
 
Further, individual members of OASIS don't treat TC formation as a "first to
pole wins" wrt charters.  OASIS provides a place for like minded individuals
to do work.  It has no structure for insisting on consistency or
relationship between TCs or other groups.  Though such is certainly
permitted, pending whether the individuals choose to.  
 
Surely these differences in processes and their plus and minues have been
obvious for years now and people shouldn't be surprised by what can happen,
or that it automatically means something *bad* for Web services.  If people
have reservations about the OASIS process, then talking about it on w3c
ws-arch seems like it would need to get moved off of the w3c pretty fast.
I'm ok with talking about the impact of various processes on web services
architecture for a while, but it's probably something that needs to be
wrapped up quickly.  Finally, people seem to like the OASIS process as lots
of work is being done there.  
 
Cheers,
Dave

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Saturday, March 15, 2003 2:34 PM
To: [email protected]; [email protected]; 'Ugo Corda';
[email protected]
Subject: RE: Questions prompted by the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging


There are differences. The primary difference that I see (after a quick
glance) is that WS-ReliableMessaging relies on/works with WS-Policy and the
other GXA specifications. WS-Reliability is a standalone SOAP extension.
Also, WS-ReliableMessaging has defined Addressability separately (which
decouples asynchronicity from reliability). I think that
WS-ReliableMessaging and WS-Addressability are better, more flexible, more
thorough, more comprehensive specifications. Even so, the specs address
exactly the same problem space. 
 
The primary difference is political. The authors of WS-ReliableMessaging
have not signed up to participate in the WS-RM TC. I'm not sure that it's a
given that the authors will submit it to the WS-RM TC. I'd say that it bodes
badly for the standardization effort. 
 
Anne

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Saturday, March 15, 2003 4:05 PM
To: [email protected]; 'Ugo Corda'; [email protected]
Subject: RE: Questions prompted by the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging


I agree with Ugo. Reading through the abstract it's obvious that we have two
specifications that solve the same problem. Is there a value in that?
 
I actually dug deeper into the specs and I can tell that there are some
differences. But most of us don't have the time to compare green apples to
red apples. It would have been much easier if someone could present a list
of the difference. If WS-ReliableMessaging does something better than WS-RM
then clearly it could be summarized in two pages and presented to the WS
community so we can judge.
 
Maybe they are so different that we need to have both. I don't see that, but
a more educated explanation would help. Maybe the changes are minor, in
which case such a comparison could help the OASIS TC in addressing the
problem of reliable messaging in a much better way.
 
Am I the only one interested in seeing such a comparison?
 
arkin

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Saturday, March 15, 2003 12:46 PM
To: 'Ugo Corda'; [email protected]
Subject: RE: Questions prompted by the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging


I suggest you need to read the specs slower rather than quicker :-)

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]On
Behalf Of Ugo Corda
Sent: Saturday, March 15, 2003 12:44 PM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Questions prompted by the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging



Probably most people in the group have had a chance by now to see this
week's announcement of the publication of WS-ReliableMessaging (see [1]).

After a quick reading of the spec, I have to say that I don't see any major
architectural/technical differences compared to the OASIS
WS-ReliableMessaging TC activity and its input document WS-Reliability (or
at least differences big enough to justify going a completely separate way).


I really hope that some WSA members whose companies published the new
reliability spec can help me clarify the previous point and provide some
architectural/technical rationale for the separate publication.

Thank you, 
Ugo 

P.S. No need to answer if the rationale for publication is a political one
(I can figure that out by myself ...). 

[1] http://xml.coverpages.org/ni2003-03-13-a.html
<http://xml.coverpages.org/ni2003-03-13-a.html>  


------=_NextPart_000_0031_01C2EC82.46888190
Content-Type: application/ms-tnef;
	name="winmail.dat"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
	filename="winmail.dat"
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------=_NextPart_000_0031_01C2EC82.46888190--