Re: [MACCAWS] Yahoo! Makeover

"Jon Dillon" <[email protected]> Mon, 30 Sep 2002 05:20:20 -0700
Newsgroups gmane.comp.web.vkit
Message-ID <[email protected]>
> >> This had been in the back of my mind for some time now, so I went
> >> ahead & gave it a shot: <http://centricle.com/lab/yahoo/>
> >
> >I'm slightly concerned about copywrite issues with doing mockups such
> >as this.
>
> Me too, but only slightly ;)
>
> FWIW, I included meta-data explicitly indicating that all the content is
indeed
> Yahoo's property, and explaining the purpose of the document. Seems like
fair
> use to me, as it's simply an academic exercise.

You know, that's true.  But the best way to get around it?  You're allowed
to parody a site under US law, as parody is actually protected under the
constitutional right to free speech.  There is a legal def and all that, but
there is a strong precident, so long as we are not seeking commercial gain.
Yahoo! may persue it, in which case we'll make it the yohoo! page, and
change all the copy/identifiable features.  Don't worry, I've done this
before.

Take a look at this page:

http://www.sierraclubbed.com/legal.html

Look for parody here:

http://www.cfpca.wayne.edu/faculty/wright/SPJ5020/15.%20Copyright,%20Free%20
Speech.html

Look, so long as it says it's a parody, and you're willing to make it comply
with a parody (easy, just take anything TMed, or (c)ed off, and replace it
with a close fakey if, and only if, Yahoo! is lame enough to care about you
given them a better version of their home page (it's possible, but they
probably won't since they're laid off some of their staff).

You can still consult an attorney, but this is really a pretty safe
proposition!  Forge ahead!

Jonathan