| Newsgroups |
gmane.culture.backpacking.backpackgeartest |
| Message-ID |
<[email protected]> |
Hello Matthew, Bob Dorenfeld is taking a sabbatical from BGT, so I shall pick up the editing of your first Owner Review. There's really only one EDIT requiring a substantive re-write, so I think one more Repost and we'll be ready to get it on the list and you on our roster.
I use the standard BGT editing format, same as Bob:
EDIT [all caps] – Must be revised.
Edit [initial cap] – Suggested change or request for clarification. Up to you unless otherwise stated.
Comment – Just that; no action required.
Please Repost after revising and include, as you did for this version, a tinyurl link to the html version in the Tests/Owner Reviews folder.
Cheers, Richard Lyon
BGT Editor
_________________________
### Height: 5 ft 10 in (177.8 cm)
Weight: 184 lb (83.5 kg) ###
Edit: This is OK, but here's a tip for better writing. Unless the Imperial measurement is precise – the summit of a peak you climbed, say – it is preferable to round off the metric conversion. Here it would be 178 cm and 83 kg.
### Date: 7 September 2015 ###
EDIT: Move this to immediately under your name in the title of the Review. A BGT convention.
### Backpacking Background
I began hiking and backpacking avidly around 12 years ago, usually taking short trips into secluded wilderness and high alpine areas. I have a preference toward rugged mountain environments where I encounter snowy and icy conditions. ###
EDIT: This is fine as far as it goes, but more information is needed. Mention your typical pack weight, typical trip length (what is "short?"), typical shelter (tent, tarp, bivy), and other indicia of your hiking style. This helps your reader evaluate your opinions. Keep in mind our 100-word limit.
### Manufacturer: Asolo ###
EDIT: Asolo S.p.a. [Here – but only here – BGT requires the full, legal name of the manufacturer. You can usually find it at the bottom of the manufacturer's home page in the copyright notice. "S.p.a." is the Italian equivalent of "Inc."]
### The Fugitive is a well stitched, full height boot ###
Edit: well-stitched [with a hyphen]
### and the light but noticeable decorative stitching patterns that run between each eyelet give the Fugitive a distinct flare ###
EDIT: flair [spelling – and one that a spellchecker won't catch. A flare illuminates the sky; flair is an element of style.]
### The lacing consists of round, nylon laces running first through a nylon loop just above the toe box then through four pairs of of metal loops. ###
EDIT: Delete the extra "of"
### The combination of the speed hooks and the metal loop eyelets allow for quick adjustments to how tightly the boot is tied.###
EDIT: allows for ["combination" is singular]
### The midsole of the boot, which Asolo refers to to as DUOAsoflex, ###
EDIT: Delete the extra "to"
### I have put over 1,000 mi (1,609 km) on two pairs of Fugitives. The second pair (pictured) have approximately 450 mi (724 km) on them. ###
Edit: Two other conversions that I'd round off to 1600 and 725 m.
### They are one of the few pairs of hiking boots that fit my narrow heel like a glove and provide lasting comfort over double-digit miles carrying up to 40 lb (18 kg) packs. ###
Comment: I agree – I have the same narrow ankles and the same problem. Asolo seems to make a narrower boot.
### I have also taken the Fugitive out in mid-winter conditions in Colorado for overnights where temps got to -2 F (-19 C).
OBSERVATIONS
The Fugitive was a gamble for me. ###
Edit: When referring to use it's better to use the plural for boots, as you usually wear both at the same time. This is also a consistency issue for you, as several times you do use "Fugitives." Check your report and strive for consistency. Sometimes, as is true of the second one here, a change might require a different verb.
### The break-in period was literally two days after replacing the stock, removable insoles with Superfeet insoles. ###
EDIT: Replace "Superfeet" with a descriptive adjective such as "aftermarket," "custom," or the like. This is another BGT convention – avoid mentioning brands other than those of the product under review unless that is necessary to explain interworking (as is true of your subsequent reference to crampons).
### on a nearly 14 mile trip ###
EDIT: Add the metric conversion, 22 km.
Edit: 14-mile [with a hyphen]
### and I had to switch often between snow shoes and crampons. ###
Edit: snowshoes [one word]
## This greatly reduced the warmth of the boot for me the next morning when putting them on. ###
Comment: Try placing your boots inside your sleeping bag, in a waterproof stuff sack. They may be wet but they'll be the right size and much easier to put on.
### The rubber toe cap provides added durability to an otherwise wear prone area and has held up very well over the years on rock strewn trails such as the Desolation trail up Mount Carrigain in New Hamshire.###
Edit: wear-prone [with a hyphen]
EDIT: New Hampshire [spelling]