Re: beyondhom Re: rubric help & thoughts needed

On Mar 30, 2012, at 12:12 AM, LynnP wrote:
> So you are assuming that her nutrition and assimilation are optimal

No. I am assuming they can be made optimal or at least reasonably complete.

> & that the cell salts like calc phos for instance

I said noting about cell salts...yet:-)

I'm quite happy with the balanced use of the twelve cell salts in 6X, but not with a specific one that has no symptoms to indicate a need for it.
Preventively, a cell salt a day - one a day for a week - for each of the twelve salts in rotation - so a twelve week regime - then repeat - is a good way to stay healthy. I've seen a couple generatios in my cousin's family use that protocol to great effect. 
But taking a lot of a single cell salt - without any pathology matching it - is neither balanced nor indicated in my view.

> , will have no effect on her and instead contribute to low self esteem?  

I did not associate cell salts wit low self esteem. I asocite a "treatment" for shortness in any way or shape, to be wrong, and to imply there is somethig wrong with a perfecetly healthy individual. THAT can cause lowself estem.From all that has been said thisgirl is healthy and needs no fixing but needs to know and accept that she is already special. Not that she needs "treatment to become normal". She's already normal.
Malnutrition would need to be gross to have any adverse effect on stature.  It's other things that look wrong in mild to moderate malnutrition.
     
> I believe that if I did not try the cell salts, at least, to maximize her growth I would be in the wrong profession.

Cell salts can't maximze her growth.
Cell salts ensure the *functional* health of individual cells of a certain type.
They do not determine how MANY cells will form or in what positions.

> You are also assuming that she is in a “healthy state”.  

In terms of her height yes.

> No where have I stated that she is in a healthy state (if you had bothered to read the firsts posts….)

No need to be rude I read your post well on 14 March. So she had a few colds.  It's normal in a vaccinated poopulation - it takes at least three  generatiosn withotu vaccines to get rid if those effects.
It's nothing to do with height.
If you prefer not to hear mny views that's fine with me.

> You wrote: “To use an extreme but valid example:
> It would be like asking homeopathy to declaw a cat.”
> 
> Whaaa?!? No, declawing a cat is not a valid example at all.

It is valid in that homepathy has a specific purpose - to build health where it is missing - and it is not to make the results of genetically determined shape into somethig other than the genes define - as in declawing.

> She has been taking the cell salts as well as remedies for her pathologies as they have presented.

But you are asking abot height/stature - and there is no sign of height/stature pathology.
Yo said there is a cultural bias - homeopahty is not for trreating humans to meet a cultural bias.
Use it rather to treat the bias in those that have it!

> In the meantime my original post was to ask if anyone on this list knew of a rubric more specific than “DEVELOPMENT, arrested” for this case and any ideas that might help.   

The arrented development is in the culture - it has failed to develop tolerance for inborn genetic traits such as shortness.
You showed no evidence that the girl's dvelopment was arrested. Just that it was culturaly not liked.
Treat the problem - the cultural issue. Not its victim - the girl (as regards stature).

> I am grateful for the people here who took the time to contribute good ideas and information but I have found your input to be non-productive

Gee thanks.
I'll try to reemer wherer not to waste my limited time again.

> and wonder why you find it necessary to insult me by inferring that I am using homeopathy to “take away health” and contributing to her low self-esteem?

What Insult? -
It was YOUR idea to try to use homeopathy to change something that the culture dislikes but which is set and fixed by genes.  That indeed would take away health. At best you'd get an aggravation from whatever remedy you chose to do the "job" of trying to make a young girl's genes go haywire, so as to better conform to cultural desires on stature.. (The genes would HAVE to go haywire to make her taller.) 
So - I do not think you'd get anything but a aggravation - but If the shoe fits.......trying to misuse homeopathy for other than best health goes against the grain for me if not for  you.

That's all I wished to convey. It's YOUR topic, and you complained of a lack of response.

If you throw tomatoes at those who bother to give a proper detailed response, with reasons, don't expect anyone to respond next time you ask.

Any insult you perceive is your choice.

Namaste,
    Irene
-- 
Irene de Villiers, B.Sc AASCA MCSSA D.I.Hom/D.Vet.Hom.
P.O. Box 4703 Spokane WA 99220.
www.angelfire.com/fl/furryboots/clickhere.html (Veterinary Homeopath.)
"Man who say it cannot be done should not interrupt one doing it."








------------------------------------

The Healing of Humanity is our ultimate goal.
The opinions expressed by posters on this list are the responsibility of the poster and do not reflect the opinion of the owner.Suggestions given on the list are not to be taken as prescriptions.Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beyondhomeopathy/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/beyondhomeopathy/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/