Re: RFC Browse Files Pane: Add ‘Show in Fi nder'

Good idea. We'll add an "Open Containing Folder" entry to the context 
menu of the "Browse Files" tool 
(http://www.xmlmind.com/xmleditor/_distrib/doc/help/browseFilesPane.html).

This menu entry will not be called "Show In Finder", which is too 
related to the Mac.

On the Mac, if macOS behavior really corresponds to what we have 
understood from the man page:

-R    Reveal the file(s) in the Finder instead of opening them.

this menu entry will indeed invoke command "open -R".

Thank you for your suggestion.



On 11/26/22 22:08, Leif H Silli wrote:
> PROPOSAL:
> 
>    Inside the CTRL Click menu of the Browse Files Pane, add a ”Reveal in 
> Finder” command and make that command call the following CLI command:
> 
>      open -R “%F”
> 
>    “Reveal in Finder” what such commands are typically called in MacOS. 
> And, to help users understand how it works, it might also be a good idea 
> to use the long version of the command:
> 
>      open --reveal “%F”
> 
> PROBLEM:
> 
>    On the Mac, there is very little integreration between XXE and the 
> MacOS Finder (AKA the file browser). For example:
> 
>    1. It is not possible to tell the system to open a file in XXE (e.g. 
> by double clicking the file in Finder or similar commands).

There is nothing we can do. This is a Java bug which seems have never 
been fixed. See  "JDK-8043852 [macosx] OpenFilesHandler does not receive 
fileopen events". https://bugs.openjdk.org/browse/JDK-8043852

Moreover, we do use the Desktop integration API 
(https://openjdk.org/jeps/272) as a replacement as suggested by Java 
developers in the bug report and it still does not work on the Mac.






>    2. And, opposite, XXE does not have a way to let the user 
> show/select/display a selected or active file in Finder.
> 
>    I know no solution to the first problem - from Finder to XXE. But, 
> the “open -R” command seems to be a rather simple solution to the second 
> problem - displaying a file in the Finder.
> 
> 
> SOLUTION:
> 
>    The solution is a MacOS solution only. However, it ought to be pretty 
> low hanging fruit, as it makes use of the CLI open command (a command 
> that we discussed earlier this month):
> 
>    In MacOS Terminal.app, if we run
> 
>      open --help
> 
>    we learn that about the “reveal” option:
> 
>        -R, --reveal          Selects in the Finder instead of opening.
> 
>    Currently, the 'Default viewer’ command is - by default (sic!) - the 
> following command:
> 
>      open "%U"
> 
>    But if we add the --reveal option, like so:
> 
>      open --reveal "%U” /* Or: open --reveal “%F” */
> 
>    Then, selecting the Preview commmand (of XXE’s XHTML menu - for 
> instance) will display the currently active file in the Finder instead 
> of sending the file to the default preview program (for XHTML files, 
> typically to the default Web browser).
> 
>    The above hack, by way of modifying the command of the Preview menu, 
> is already possible. However, to make use of the Preview menu option for 
> this, *is* a hack. Also, it requires that one opens the file in XXE, 
> before one can run the command. A better solution, would be to add a 
> submenu called ‘Reveal in Finder’ to the local CTRL Click menu of the 
> 'Browse Files Pane'. Then one can display any file in the Finder, 
> including files that XXE itself is unable to display.
> 


--
XMLmind XML Editor Support List
[email protected]
http://www.xmlmind.com/mailman/listinfo/xmleditor-support