Re: A little information on hemlock
Ralph Hancock <[email protected]>
| Newsgroups | gmane.education.classics |
|---|---|
| Message-ID | <CALBWZwZa-vUt64Y4OTWVz=dg__-mEr3OmTo=LNML8gF01C5qFw@mail.gmail.com> |
A little information is a dangerous thing; Drink deep, or take a very long detour of at least fifty miles around the good old Pierian spring. 'Hemlock' is a very vague name given to various plants. The hemlock that Socrates is said to have drunk comes from an umbelliferous plant, _Conium maculatum_, which is not native to the United States, and its presence in a wood in Washington is most unlikely. Its principal poisonous substance is coniin. There is a loosely related group of umbellifers in the United States called water hemlock, _Cicuta_ species, whose poison is cicutoxin. But the most common use of the name 'hemlock' in the USA is, I think, to refer to the hemlock tree, a coniferous tree and one of several _Tsuga_ species, none of which is poisonous. I have seen accounts of Socrates' death that claim that he would have suffered painful convulsions as he went. These are symptoms of _Cicuta_ poisoning but not, as far as I can discover, of poisoning by _C. maculatum_. RH