Re: Setting 'which-key-dont-use-unicode'

Justin Burkett <[email protected]> writes:

> Hi,
>
> First, don't set which-key-mode as a custom variable. This is a
> function that should be called after which-key is loaded.

That shouldn't be an issue or discouraged, all minor modes are
intentionally user options that enable the minor mode when set using
:custom, setopt, custom-set-variables, etc.

> For your original question, the important thing is that
> which-key-dont-use-unicode is set before which-key is loaded. (c)
> definitely won't work for this reason. 

It shouldn't be necessary, or at least that is what the custom setter of
`which-key-dont-use-unicode' should provide.  And evaluating these
expressions in order does indicate that this works:

  which-key-dont-use-unicode ;=> t
  which-key-separator ;=> " : "
  (setopt which-key-dont-use-unicode nil)
  which-key-separator ;=> " → "
  

>                                        The fact that (d) is working,
> which takes this logic to the extreme, but the others are not suggests
> that something is causing which-key to load before the variable is
> set.
>
> Combining the two ideas, try
>
> (use-package which-key
>   :custom
>   (which-key-dont-use-unicode nil)
>   :config
>   (which-key-mode t))
>
> If that doesn't work, look for another culprit that might be loading
> which-key (perhaps because it depends on it) earlier.
>
> Justin
>
> On Sun, Jun 23, 2024 at 5:05 PM Kévin Le Gouguec
> <[email protected]> wrote:
>>
>> Hello!
>>
>> Paging help-gnu-emacs before filing a bug because I'm not sure of the
>> intended behavior.  After seeing 2024-06-18 "Disable usage of unicode
>> for which-key by default" (cc0a3a5f65b), I promptly went to my .emacs to
>> opt in to Unicode symbols, and was surprised to meet some resistance.
>>
>> In an Emacs built from 2024-06-23 "; Fix typos" (fb11294d415) on the
>> emacs-30 branch, I tried
>>
>>   (a) this .emacs:
>>
>>     (use-package which-key
>>       :custom
>>       (which-key-dont-use-unicode nil)
>>       (which-key-mode t))
>>
>>   (b) this .emacs:
>>
>>     (custom-set-variables
>>      '(which-key-dont-use-unicode nil)
>>      '(which-key-mode t))
>>
>>   (c) an empty .emacs, then
>>
>>     M-x which-key-mode
>>     M-x toggle-option which-key-dont-use-unicode
>>
>>   (d) a combination of this .emacs:
>>
>>     (use-package which-key
>>       :custom
>>       (which-key-mode t))
>>
>>   with this .emacs.d/early-init.el:
>>
>>     (setq which-key-dont-use-unicode nil)
>>
>> and only attempt (d) yielded which-key messages with '→' instead of ':'
>> for the separator symbol (resp. '…' instead of '..'  for truncation).
>>
>> Wondering if I am doing something wrong (a definite possibility, the
>> perils of juggling ${HOME}s for repro purposes), if (d) really is the
>> intended way to effectively unset which-key-dont-use-unicode, or if this
>> is a potential bug report or feature request?

No, it is not.  I think this sounds like a bug.  Try to reproduce this
with emacs -Q and perhaps step through the definitions using edebug,
because as mentioned above, it seems to work for me.