Re: Are you kiddihng me Thorin?????

Eric --

Please stop claiming what the DPjudge does and does not care about.  Thorin
is free to decide not to allow you to join games that he Masters, and this
has nothing to do with the DPjudge.  You have not been banned from the judge
itself, only from being allowed (by one human being, Thorin) to join games
that he Masters.  I am sure he has his reasons.

As far as Peter Schnabl, you don't tell a complete story; for example, he
was elminated in game "avocado", which ended in a draw that did not include
his power.

As the founder of the DPjudge and judgekeeper of USDP, I will be happy to
prosecute and ban anyone who has violated house rules.  Winning games does
not constitute a violation.  Somehow getting other players to assist you in
doing so also does not.  There is no hard evidence whatsoever to indicate
any collusion in any game, outside the game by Mr. Schnabl, and from what I
understand, the player that you accused of being his alter-ego lives half a
world away from him.

Were I to guess, those people who have followed Mr. Schnabl's advice and
ended up on the short end of the stick seeing him eat their dots were not
completely on board with the way it ended up, and if they were, I am sure
they had their reasons, likely to see Mr. Schnabl succeed in order to make a
point or otherwise punish some other player in the game for their behaviour.

Anyway, I would appreciate it if accusations of cheating be made through the
GM and then directly to the judgekeeper, and were kept off the general
DPjudge mailing list, which is read by DPjudge players in general.

Stab you soon,
Manus




On Sun, Dec 26, 2010 at 5:41 PM, Been Chissled <[email protected]> wrote:

> I have just been band for pointing out a clear cheater.  Thorin would
> rather act as if a person called on cheating who has solo'd every game he
> has played isn't cheating because he sent presses .  Thorin you are a weak
> excuse for a game master these days.  Clearly Austria "Peter Schnabl" was
> cheating.  So I guess it's point out the cheater and it's easier to kick out
> the person pointing out the problem than doing something about the problem.
>  So whom do I talk to about Thorin?  This is crap.  Look at the play I
> mentioned and note Three owls games, Three solo's, in each solo game a
> another player fell on their sword for Peter for no good reason.  Guess the
> DPJudge dosen't care about cheating?
>
>
>
> ------------------------------------
>
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>
>