RE: : digest issue 11 closure (fwd)

John Loughney writes...

> What you are suggesting is
> that we should dumb-down Diameter SIP so that it can live
> with RADIUS.  However, I don't think we have a requirement for
> this.

Well, the RADEXT WG *does* have a requirement that RADIUS extensions be
interoperable with Diameter.  I guess what you're saying is that the AAA
WG does *not* have a requirement that Diameter be interoperable with
RADIUS extensions.

There are two SIP Digest Authentication protocols, one in Diameter and
one in RADIUS.  My understanding is that one originated in 3GPP and the
other originated in 3GPP2.  Are you suggesting that these are disjoint
solution sets that need not interoperate?