Re: : Issue: differences betweern 3GPP SIP usage and Diameter SIP document

Jari Arkko <[email protected]> Wed, 26 Oct 2005 18:00:20 +0300
Newsgroups gmane.ietf.aaa
Message-ID <[email protected]>
[email protected] wrote:

>Hari,
>
>Is there any reason why your colleague didn't participate in the
>WG discussions?  There have been 3 WG last calls, which is ample
>opportunity for people to contribute to this work.
>  
>
Don't blame my colleague, blame me -- I've been too
busy in the last weeks to send this in, even if I had
it earlier. Sorry. Also, there are a lot of folks
working on Cx in many companies, most likely
including the authors of the spec.

By the way, we are not raising this as an issue
that must be corrected. We are raising this as
a difference, with an intent to provide information
that may or may not be useful in making the
protocol more likely to be adopted at a particular
user community.

I agree that the data is raw. Many of the items
are simply resulting from the fact that Cx is
a vendor specific protocol. Some additional
work would be needed to determine if there's
any difference that is worth changing Diameter
SIP for.

--Jari