RE: RE: draft-ietf-adslmib-vdsl-ext-scm-06

Here is my review (a bit later than I had hoped/promised):

SMICng tells me now:
  E: f(vdslscm.mi2), (1,1) Construct "TEXTUAL-CONVENTION" used
     in VDSL-LINE-EXT-SCM-MIB, but not defined or imported

You must IMPORT the TEXTUAL -CONVENTION

  E: f(vdslscm.mi2), (82,11) Leading sub-Id "transmission" is
     not known in current module

You must IMPORT transmission

  E: f(vdslscm.mi2), (431,17) Item "vdslLineSCMConfProfileBandId"
     in object-group "vdslLineExtSCMGroup" has access of
     "not-accessible"

normally, not-accessible objecst should not be losted in an object group


  W: f(vdslscm.mi2), (13,5) "vdslMIB" imported but not used

You no longer should IMPORT vdslMIB if not used.

Pls fix syntax errors first.

You can extract the MIB and send it to [email protected]
which will then send back a SYNTAX report.
For help, just send subjectline help to [email protected]

Bert