Re: Negative feedback to our proposals

On Wed, Oct 15, 2003 at 05:20:37PM -0400, Meng Weng Wong wrote:
> I have reviewed the list of objections.  Nobody says anything new, and
> the first objection is based on the usual misunderstanding that
> designated sender affects header From.


Sure, it is not new. They are still the same objections as discussed
on ASRG, but we still didn't manage to convince people about our
proposals. 

Even if the objections are ten years old and have been repeated
hundred times, we still need to address them. If people do not accept
our proposal, we've missed the point, no matter whether objections
were good or new.

These objections were exactly what I received to my former drafts
(beyond tons of positive feedback), but I wanted to give you some 
"fresh" ones. That's what we have to cope with if we write a combined
draft.

Hadmut