Implementation Report for Remote Operations MIB modules

Hi Bert -

In preparation for advancing the disman Remote Operations MIB
modules to Draft Standard, here are implementation reports for the
DISMAN-PING-MIB, the DISMAN-TRACROUTE-MIB, and the
DISMAN-NSLOOKUP-MIB.  There were at least two independent
implementations of each of these.  There was at least
one freely-available implementation ("B") for all
three MIB modules.

Implementation |  Submitted By   |         Submitter's        |
     Report    |                 |           Address          |
---------------+-----------------+----------------------------+
        B      | J. Chen         | [email protected]       |
        R      | Govind Haridass | [email protected] |
        J      | Daniel Chuang   | [email protected]        |
        E      | John Scano      | [email protected]         |

Note that "E" and "J" were done by different groups at
Juniper, and were reported separately.


Report | Implementation Source
-------+-------------------------------------------------------
   B   | Beijing University of Posts and Telecommunications
       | Network Information Center
   E   | Juniper (E-Series routers)
   J   | Juniper
   R   | SNMP Research


Module: DISMAN-PING-MIB

Groups                 | Implementation |
Implemented            | B  |  J  |  R  |
-----------------------+----+-----+-----+
pingGroup              |  y |  y  |  y  |
pingNotificationsGroup |  y |  y  |  y  |
pingTimeStampGroup     |  y |  y  |  y  |


There were reports on three independent implementations, and all
supported all three object groups in this MIB module.  Additional
details on the individual objects implemented:

OBJECT-TYPE                    | Implementation |
access supported               | B  |  J  |  R  |
-------------------------------+----+-----+-----+
pingMaxConcurrentRequests      | -  | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlStorageType             | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlType                    | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlByPassRouteTable        | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlSourceAddressType       | rw | rw  | rw  |
            unknown            | n  | y   | n   |
            ipv4               | n  | y   | y   |
            ipv6               | n  | n   | n   |
pingCtlSourceAddress           | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlIfIndex                 | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingCtlDSField                 | rw | rw  | rw  |
pingResultsIpTargetAddressType | ro | ro  | ro  |
            unknown            | y  | y   | n   |
            ipv4               | y  | y   | y   |
            ipv6               | y  | n   | n   |
pingResultsIpTargetAddress     | ro | ro  | ro  |
     0                         | y  | y   |     |
     4                         | y  | y   |     |
     16                        | y  | n   |     |




Module: DISMAN-TRACEROUTE-MIB

There were reports on three independent implementations of
the DISMAN-TRACROUTE-MIB, and all three supported all four
groups.

Groups                       | Implementation |
Implemented                  | B  |  J  |  R  |
-----------------------------+----+-----+-----+
traceRouteGroup              | y  |  Y  |  Y  |
traceRouteTimeStampGroup     | y  |  Y  |  Y  |
traceRouteNotificationsGroup | y  |  Y  |  Y  |
traceRouteHopsTableGroup     | y  |  Y  |  Y  |


Additional details on support of specific OBJECT-TYPES:

OBJECT-TYPE                     | Implementation |
access supported                | B  |  J  |  R  |
--------------------------------+----+-----+-----+
traceRouteMaxConcurrentRequests | -  | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlByPassRouteTable   | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlSourceAddressType  | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlSourceAddress      | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlIfIndex            | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlMiscOptions        | rw | rw  | ro  |
traceRouteCtlStorageType        | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlDSField            | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteCtlType               | rw | rw  | rw  |
traceRouteResultsIpTgtAddrType  |    |     |     |
        unknown                 | y  | y   | n   |
        ipv4                    | y  | y   | y   |
        ipv6                    | y  | n   | n   |
traceRouteResultsIpTgtAddr      |    |     |     |
        0                       | y  | y   |     |
        4                       | y  | y   |     |
        16                      | y  | n   |     |
traceRouteProbeHistoryHAddrType |    |     |     |
        unknown                 | y  | y   | n   |
        ipv4                    | y  | y   | y   |
        ipv6                    | y  | n   | n   |
traceRouteProbeHistoryHAddr     |    |     |     |
        0                       | y  | y   |     |
        4                       | y  | y   |     |
        16                      | y  | n   |     |
traceRouteHopsIpTgtAddressType  |    |     |     |
        unknown                 | y  | y   | n   |
        ipv4                    | y  | y   | n   |
        ipv6                    | y  | n   | n   |
traceRouteHopsIpTgtAddress      |    |     |     |
        0                       | y  | y   |     |
        4                       | y  | y   |     |
        16                      | y  | n   |     |


Module: DISMAN-NSLOOKUP-MIB

There were two reports of implementations of the
DISMAN-NSLOOKUP-MIB module.  Both implemented the
mandatory object group for lookupCompliance, which
is a superset of the lookupMinimumComplaince.


Groups                       | Implementation |
Implemented                  |   B   |   E    |
-----------------------------+----------------+
lookupGroup                  |   y   |   y    |


Additional details on support of specific OBJECT-TYPES:

OBJECT-TYPE                     | Implementation |
access supported                |   B     |  E   |
--------------------------------+---------+------+
lookupMaxConcurrentRequests     | n (?)   |  y   |
lookupPurgeTime                 | n (?)   |  y   |
lookupCtlTargetAddressType      |         |      |
      ipv4                      |   y     |  y   |
      ipv6                      |   y     |  y   |
      dns                       |   y     |  y   |
lookupCtlTargetAddress          |         |      |
      ipv4                      |   y     |  y   |
      ipv6                      |   y     |  y   |
      dns                       |   y     |  y   |
lookupResultsAddressType        |         |      |
      ipv4                      |   y     |  y   |
      ipv6                      |   y     |  y   |
      dns                       |   y     |  y   |
lookupResultsAddress            |         |      |
      ipv4                      |   y     |  y   |
      ipv6                      |   y     |  y   |
      dns                       |   y     |  y   |