Entity State MIB Status

"Sharon Chisholm" <[email protected]> Thu, 22 Jul 2004 09:31:54 -0400
Newsgroups gmane.ietf.entmib
Message-ID <[email protected]>
hi

Ok. I just finished doing the math and while I was able to move a number of
the issues to resolved, the following issues had either small portions of
the proposed edit that I missed in -04 or had small bits where I want to
double check something before closing.

 307 'notSupported' is semantically wrong 
	- This has been changed to 'unavailable'. Some people had wanted
'unknown'. Should
		I have changed this to unknown?

 311 DateAndTimeOrZero   
	- Didn't really have proposed resolution or rather we had a couple
comments after 
		the proposed resolution

 322 Textual Convention Names (Prefix) 
	- I just missed the prefix during the edit. It is in a separate
module though.
	- I will update with an 'Entity' prefix

 325  <MIB OID values>
	- I thought I made this change, but apparently didn't. I will make
it.
  
 333 Relationship with Alarm MIB open entity-state
	- The open bit of this is whether the Alarm MIB should be a
normative or 
		informative reference. I think it's a bit of a grey area so
propose leaving
	      it where it is for now.

 334 Table, Index Descriptions open entity-state
	- I think the changes reflect what people were looking for, but I
wasn't sure. 

 354 More Editorial Changes (2)  
	- I'm not sure what is wrong with the term 'reports' so I can't
suggest a 
		replacement
      - We haven't yet discussed this one, but adding X.731 to the Reference
clause was 
	 a previous editing instruction based either on consensus or a
suggestion from the
	area director - I forget which. I propose keeping it.

Sharon Chisholm
Portfolio Integration
Nortel Networks
Ottawa, Canada